3 ms·
Crystallographer faked data
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ggruschow 17y agoWhat does this guy's future look like now? Nobody'll give him a job in science right? Is there any way he can use his expertise outside of starting his own company that somehow monetizes it? Would he be accepted as a high-school teacher?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- RK 17y agoSomething like this happened/is happening to a professor that I worked for in grad school. He has retracted several papers and will probably be retracting at least one more from top journals (Nature, Science, etc). Fortunately for me I was only in the group for a very short time and never had any publications as a result. This can't be said for the other students I knew in the group, although it was one of the grad student co-authors who apparently "turned him in". My assessment of the situation is that the prof is extremely capable, but the pressures of being a tenure-track assistant professor, probably combined with the arrogance of thinking he could get away with faking data, made it too tempting. I think he will certainly end up shut out of academia, but at the same time I don't think you'll hear about it, because too many people stand to lose face if it is publicized. I think this is probably the most common outcome of "scientific misconduct" when it is actually caught and punished.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jackfoxy 17y agoA timely article, given some higher profile accusations that have recently surfaced... Newton appears to have faked experimental data in the optical research he published, in that he interpolated experimental results to accuracies he could not possibly have measured. Academic standards were a little different in those days.
- Evgeny 17y agoWere the journals that published his articles peer-reviewed or not?