6 ms·
Be careful about the victimless label. Just because an individual action does not cause harm does not mean that it should not be punished as if it had. The ac
by sandworm101 11y ago
Be careful about the victimless label. Just because an individual action does not cause harm does not mean that it should not be punished as if it had. The act is the same. Whether or not someone is physically injured is largely a matter of luck. It would be horrific if punishments were handed out on that basis alone.
A long time ago I read a statement from a judge sentencing two defendants for felony murder. They both shot and a man was dead, but there was a debate as to which bullet actually killed. "The only difference between the two was aim, and I am not going to let one off for being the poorer shot."
The more appropriate word for such laws are "regulatory crimes". They are meant to regulate behavior to prevent or reduce an evil that does not occur in all cases. This covers everything from practicing medicine without a license to drug possession, neither of which necessarily cause a physical harm in every case.
- gnaritas 11y agoAnd yet, punishing people who haven't hurt anyone seems far worse the crime. Victim-less isn't a label, it's a statement of fact that no one was hurt and thus cannot claim injury; there should be no such crimes. "Regulatory crime" is way of putting a soft label on a terrible practice, punishing the innocent just because something "might" have happened. What you call luck, others call knowing their limits.
- tempestn 11y agoI know you may not mean this literally, but taken at face value, you're saying even attempted murder (assuming you don't end up harming your intended victim) shouldn't be a crime. I would actually argue that an attempted murder should be considered almost as great, if not as great, a crime as one that succeeded. Similarly for most crimes, in my opinion the intent is at least as important as the act itself. Basically just because someone hasn't been hurt, it doesn't mean that a behaviour is acceptable in society.
- unfamiliar 11y agoNobody gets into a car drunk with the intention of harming someone else. With attempted murder there is clear intent to do harm. A better comparison would be to manslaughter - if you do something dangerous which leads to the accidental death of somebody you are punished. The question would be, if you do something dangerous and nobody happens to be hurt, should you still be punished? Should "attempted manslaughter" be a thing?
- rayiner 11y agoNo, but they do get into the car reckless as to harming someone else, which is a culpable state of mind as well. E.g. You shoot a gun into the air in downtown Chicago and the bullet happens not to kill anyone on the way back down. You didn't mean to kill any body, but it certainly was criminally reckless. Besides that, you can't have your cake and eat it too. Why is manslaughter different than murder? The only difference is the intent--the end result is the same (someone's dead). When the state of mind is the same, why should luck in the outcome change the punishment?
- gnaritas 11y ago> No, but they do get into the car reckless as to harming someone else False, you can be charged with DUI while perfectly sober; DUI applies to far more than alcohol. > Why is manslaughter different than murder? Manslaughter means accidental, murder means on purpose; if you don't see the difference, perhaps you need to think about that a bit harder. > When the state of mind is the same, why should luck in the outcome change the punishment? If you don't see the difference between an accident and doing something on purpose as requiring different punishment, well then you just fundamentally disagree with about all of mankind. If your car tire blows and you hit another car and kill someone through no fault of your own, apparently you think that's an equal crime to murder. Really... c'mon... really?
- heartbreak 11y agoYSK 'rayiner is a lawyer.
- conceit 11y ago> (assuming you don't end up harming your intended victim) > I would actually argue that an attempted murder should be considered almost as great, if not as great, a crime as one that succeeded. You are implicitly saying that it does harm. Indeed, it does harm the psych, which might lead to physical harm in the long run.
- clarky07 11y agoIt would harm my psyche if I thought everyone on the road has been drinking. I actively avoid it during times when it is in fact more likely (New Years eve etc). People who think they know their limits kill people all the time.
- gnaritas 11y ago> People who think they know their limits kill people all the time. So do people who are tired, or old, or stressed, or any other number of reasons. People kill people all the time, singling out one group and basically charging them with pre-crimes is not just. The world is a dangerous place, jailing people so your "psyche" feels good is not just. The world is dangerous, how about you accept that and act accordingly rather than supporting jailing those who haven't hurt anyone.
- clarky07 11y agoPerhaps, but drinking and driving is quite a bit more preventable than being stressed. Certainly people get distracted and accidents happen, but purposely driving impaired is in fact something different. That being said, generally speaking, a drunk driver who happens to not do anything wrong on the road is extremely unlikely to have any legal issues. Mostly they are going to have problems when they start swerving or exhibiting signs of being impaired. A tired driver who is swerving wildly is also likely to get pulled over.
- gnaritas 11y agoDUI punishes more than the impaired. > That being said, generally speaking, a drunk driver who happens to not do anything wrong on the road is extremely unlikely to have any legal issues. That might be true if it weren't for things like DUI checkpoints, which make it untrue. You can be perfectly fine to drive and still get caught and punished because of what are essentially baseless mass searches.
- titanomachy 11y agoSo you're suggesting that people be allowed, for example, to practice medicine without a license right up to the point that they kill someone through incompetence?
- adanto6840 11y agoYou bring up a great point. I'd argue that, instead of being required to go to medical school, you should be tested on the merits. If you meet the objective bar (no lawyer pun intended, though see California's attempt at doing this for the legal profession), then yes, you should be able to practice even without a multi-year degree.
- smt88 11y agoOne could consider med school to be a series of tests on the merits, including the subsequent internship/residency and licensing standards. It's just not possible to study at home and be educated enough to be a doctor. You need huge amounts of expensive resources (cadavers, equipment, live patients, etc.)
- gnaritas 11y ago> One could consider med school to be a series of tests on the merits, including the subsequent internship/residency and licensing standards. Only if one doesn't understand that medical schools are a cartel. There are far more people qualified and willing to be doctors than are allowed to be doctors, cartels have to keep their supply low to keep their wages high.
- nmrm2 11y agoThis makes more sense for professions that are "all books", so to say. E.g. law, where all you really need is a slightly longer test (or not even that). But this makes no sense for medical school, which teaches a lot that would be extremely difficult to test directly. Often the direct test would basically amount to going to medical school for some non-trivial amount of time anyways.