5 ms·
I have argued this many times, but it usually gets heated on the internet where someone undoubtably knows someone who died from a drunk driver. That said I hone
by donatj 11y ago
I have argued this many times, but it usually gets heated on the internet where someone undoubtably knows someone who died from a drunk driver. That said I honestly believe the far and vast majority of drunk driving is victimless, and probably less dangerous than distracted driving.
- underwater 11y agoMaybe the reason people keep telling you that you are wrong is not because they're overly emotional or biased, but because you're actually wrong.
- kbenson 11y agoI think the difference between distracted driving and drunk driving is the foreknowledge of impairment, and intentional increase of danger to the public. As such, in many states driving while texting or on the phone without a hands-free system are also illegal. The reasoned decision that someone's convenience is above the safety of the public is what I see as the problem here (and of course if someone isn't sober enough to make a reasoned decision about that, then I definitely don't think they have any place operating a piece of heavy equipment).
- bobwaycott 11y ago> foreknowledge of impairment, and intentional increase of danger to the public. That sounds to me exactly like distracted driving.
- kbenson 11y agoYes, as in using a phone or being subject to a perception altering substance, as I stated. But you can also become distracted while driving without the ability to quickly stop driving. This could be the fault of the driver (paying attention to irrelevant things), or out of their control (conditions warrant splitting your attention between the road in front of you an another circumstance you have no control over). We don't punish these because we person is either not willfully causing the situation, or there is no way to determine if their behavior contributed. Another way to think of it is that you aren't punished for drunk driving, but for breaking the law, and the law has been decided by determining that drunken driving provides unacceptable risk overall. Whether individually a person would have caused harm is irrelevant, we create a enforce laws for the good of all, and without enforcement, or selective enforcement without due process, we have a slew of other problems.
- bobwaycott 11y agoYou were remarking on the difference between distracted driving and drunk driving. I was replying that your stated difference did not sound like a difference at all. Given the context of the surrounding discussion, I didn't think anyone was talking about situations of accidental distraction while driving.
- kbenson 11y agoI was trying to additionally distinguish between accidental and intentional distracted driving, because I find that when a distinction can be made like that but it isn't made clear, people end up talking past each other about slightly different things but with the same name. I was a bit unclear in what I was doing though.
- bobwaycott 11y agoWise enough. I suppose I was taking it for granted that we were discussing intentional actions that place others in danger, and automatically excluding accidents.
- brohoolio 11y agoGenerally when you know someone who has died because of the choices of someone else it impacts how you view those choices. I was in physical therapy next to someone who wasn't going to walk again because of a chronic drunk driver. Distracted driving / texting while driving should be punished on the same level as drunk driving IMHO. It's really dangerous and until it's actively enforced people are going to get hurt often. I ride my bike to work and it is so dangerous because of people texting. I've seen several accidents happen because one driver is texting and the one in front of them has to stop.
- serge2k 11y agoYeah, but all the other times where the drunk didn't hit someone it was victimless. So no need to try to stop him going out and driving drunk yet again.
- walshemj 11y agoIf your commute is anything like London its the HGV (large trucks) vehicles that are the killers not texting while driving. 90% or so of the fatalities in london are caused by cyclists undertaking HGV's who turn into them.
- logiclabs 11y agoThat's only the number of fatalities. A large number of serious injury occurs across a wider range of vehicles than just HGV's. I'd say the majority are probably down to poor driving judgement, and a modest number are due to distractions. A lot of these HGV injuries are to do with bad road design and poor cyclist judgement - pulling along side the left-hand side of a HGV while it's stationery into both the drivers blind spot and being unable to see the vehicles indicators. A few of the fatalities I know of were pretty unnecessary, since there are more than adequate cycle paths to skip around the dangerous sections of road. The Elephant and Castle roundabout is particularly notorious, but is surrounded by much safer cycle paths. Despite this, a large majority of cyclists stick to the highly dangerous road, and probably the same majority that decide to risk running red lights. (I am a cyclist, so I'm not starting a cyclist vs driver debate)