3 ms·
As a parent of a difficult child, this is not at all surprising. What little evidenced-based parenting advice is out there[1] suggests the same thing: taken in
by aidenn0 11y ago
As a parent of a difficult child, this is not at all surprising.
What little evidenced-based parenting advice is out there[1] suggests the same thing: taken individually, immediate minor punishments are as effective as major punishments. The big advantage comes with the fact that the parent can be more consistent as minor punishments are typically less work than large ones. Consistent annoyances are better at provoking change than occasional calamity.
1: If you thought the story for evidence-based medicine was bad, just skim through the parenting books at a book store.
- DenisM 11y agoIt's not the novelty of this approach that excites me, it's the evidence of it working so well. We can take this data to a legislature and lobby for new treatment plans. A parent's hunch will not carry the same weight.
- joshuapants 11y agoEvidence-based politics is even less popular than evidence-based medicine.
- DenisM 11y agoI think your point is too blunt in its cynicism, it's not too useful this way. Evidence is currency, and so are demagoguery, posturing, campaign money, endorsements, promises, actual political platform, public sentiments, etc. Sadly, evidence does not trump all else. Luckily, even a modest amount of evidence currency can tip the scales of the outcome. I would like to draw your attention to a media campaign waged in recent month by forces unknown to reduce harshness of the US criminal justice system. It's pretty much every week that I get to read an article about in the New York Times, and they all refer to some sort of research being released, or a small investigation into a particular injustice. Now we get this article from the Wall Street Journal. You know it's on when both the NYT and the WSJ converge on something. The tide is turning rapidly away from "Tough On Crime" to "Measured Response", and this evidence will be a contributing factor in this sea-change.
- smt88 11y agoActually, you're wrong about evidence. People become more steadfast in their opinions in the light of evidence.[1] 1. http://youarenotsosmart.com/2011/06/10/the-backfire-effect/ http://youarenotsosmart.com/2011/06/10/the-backfire-effect/
- toddsiegel 11y agoDo you have a link or book about this to share for a new parent?
- aidenn0 11y agoMost of my research has been for dealing with kids that have trauma backgrounds, and there are different things you do there. I will say that I've found the Love & Logic series less terrible than most of the mainstream stuff, and you'll likely be able to find a local class, which (assuming you're not a single parent) can be huge on getting you on the same page with your significant-other. That made a big difference for me, as my wife and I were raised very differently. A few snippets of advice: * Operant Conditioning[2] works both ways: your child's behavior will affect you, and you will subconsciously avoid things that are distressing to you. Not taking this into account can cause a lot of problems. * One thing at a time. e.g. don't potty train and teach table manners at the same time. Partly because it's harder on the kids, but mainly to prevent burnout for the parents. * Focus primarily on having a positive relationship (versus a lot of training & discipline) with kids under about 2. It seems likely that Martha Sears[1] went overboard, but there is definitely some phenomena like "attachment." (Also, Attachment Parenting, Attachment therapy and Attachment-based therapy are all different things, and the terminology is not always agreed upon) 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_parenting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attachment_parenting 2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning
- danieltillett 11y agoYes children are experts at manipulating their parents. When you think about it they are on average as smart as their parents, but they have the advantage that their full time job is getting their parent to do what they want. Parents really don’t stand a chance.
- bitJericho 11y agoParents ar so much more experienced though. Reverse psychology works well even into the early teen years. How many parents fall for blatant reverse psychology. That's just one example of many techniques. Others include conditioning, reinforcement, outright education.
- icelancer 11y ago>1: If you thought the story for evidence-based medicine was bad, just skim through the parenting books at a book store. Yes. All the ridiculous advice my partner and I get about our children is unbelievable. And I'm someone who had to self-diagnose medical issues after years of being ignored by doctors and other "experts" who wouldn't look at evidence-based approaches. I thought it couldn't get worse. But it does. Oh, it does... so much worse.
- dlss 11y agoThe result here isn't what you said: > taken individually, immediate minor punishments are as effective as major punishments The result here is that frequent minor punishments are 72% more effective than infrequent major punishments (see the article on Hawaii's 5 year study of this approach linked to by https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10064425 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10064425).
- jeorgun 11y agoIf I'm understanding right, grandparent isn't saying "effectiveness(minor, frequent) == effectiveness(major, infrequent)"; they're saying "effectiveness(minor) == effectiveness(major) && effectiveness(frequent) > effectiveness(infrequent)".
- aidenn0 11y agoThat's exactly what I was saying, though this (and my original comment) was a simplification.
- aidenn0 11y agoThat seems completely consistent with my original quote of "Consistent annoyances are better at provoking change than occasional calamity." My point was a single minor punishment is about as effective as a single major punishment. It's more complicated than that of course, (sometimes a single major punishment is more effective, sometimes a major punishment is actually counterproductive), but in any event, frequency seems to be much more important than severity.
- proactivesvcs 11y agoThis explains why my friends and family who use the "Naughty Step" seem to have discipline down to a T. I have even heard a few stories of kids putting themselves on the Naughty Step. Even as someone who's not a parent, when I have done babysitting for said parents, I'm able to use the Naughty Step without fuss.
- stcredzero 11y agoPerhaps this also applies to industries? There seem to be a lot of 50 year old nuclear plants. There also seems to be greater impetus to upgrade natural gas turbines. Maybe we need to favor machines/processes/designs that fail early and fail often, as opposed to ones that rarely fail but in catastrophic ways?