6 ms·
Efficiency? What efficiency?! CA farmers are increasing nut trees acreage because nut trees require a lot of water, and thus nut prices are going up in the curr
by trhway 11y ago
Efficiency? What efficiency?! CA farmers are increasing nut trees acreage because nut trees require a lot of water, and thus nut prices are going up in the current drought, and thus the farmers are rushing to increase the production of such profitable product. (Heard on NPR)
- abandonliberty 11y agoSimple: Charge appropriately for water.
- thaumaturgy 11y agoHere's a print version of the NPR story you're talking about: http://www.npr.org/2015/08/06/430077437/the-twisty-logic-of-the-drought-grow-thirsty-crops-to-dig-deeper-wells http://www.npr.org/2015/08/06/430077437/the-twisty-logic-of-... I looked it up because I thought there was no way that it could be true, you must've missed some important detail. But no, the article says exactly what you said it does. What a perfect example of the intersection of the free market and the tragedy of the commons.
- liber8 11y agoIts not a tragedy of the commons. Charge market prices for water and this goes away.
- thaumaturgy 11y agoIt's almost the definitive example of the tragedy of the commons. How do you propose charging market prices for privately pumped well water?
- icebraining 11y agoPrivatize the groundwater?
- mapt 11y agoIt's a tragedy of the commons until you charge market prices for water. Privatization, regulation, collectivization, adaptive fees / "market pricing" - these are solutions proposed to situations which resemble the tragedy of the commons, in order that we can avoid the worst case scenario associated with continued individually-incentivized over-exploitation. The term refers to situations where these incentives operating on a common good line up in a way which is potentially self-destructive to the system - not strictly to situations where they've already destroyed the system.
- cortesoft 11y agoYes, if you start charging for the 'common', then you can avoid the tragedy of the common. They would first have to outlaw pumping your own water in order to start charging market price for it.
- anigbrowl 11y agoIt's a tragedy of the commons because groundwater is legally a common resource that anyone can exploit as they see fit. You can't charge market prices for it without changing that picture and declaring that someone else (eg the state) has a property interest in the groundwater, at which point it's no longer in the commons.
- tomcam 11y agoGroundwater is not exploitable as people see fit in Oregon. http://www.water-law.com/water-rights-articles/domestic-groundwater-exemption/ http://www.water-law.com/water-rights-articles/domestic-grou... edit: proper link
- anigbrowl 11y agoOK, but this article is about California and the article even mentions that California is exceptional among the states in having this approach. Groundwater is freely exploitable here: http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_info/water_rights_process.shtml#rights http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrights/board_info/water_r...
- animefan 11y agoCA farmers are increasing nut trees acreage because nut trees require a lot of water, and thus nut prices are going up in the current drought It simply isn't possible for things to happen the way you describe them. Prices are a function of supply and demand. When you say "nut trees require a lot of water, and thus nut prices are going up in the current drought" this implies that supply of nuts went down during the drought. Otherwise, consumers would have no reason to care about the amount of water required to produce nuts. Given this, "CA farmers are increasing nut trees acreage" must be an incomplete picture. Even if some farmers are increasing acreage, there must be others who are decreasing by even more, otherwise prices would be going down, not up.
- encoderer 11y agoOr, yields have dropped in the drought so farmers are forced to increase acreage? Probably that?
- animefan 11y agoThat could well have happened, but that's not my point. I was critiquing a certain mechanism, which claimed that an increase to input costs could, in itself, cause in increase in supply.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I was critiquing a certain mechanism, which claimed that an increase to input costs could, in itself, cause in increase in supply. That was not the claim. The claim was that an decrease in supply of one input (water) could drive market conditions which lead to an increase in consumption (in the course of production) of another input (land use).
- kbenson 11y agoWhat you're missing is that water is not an input cost for many of these farmers. The farmers that have cheaper access to water are increasing production of these same water intensive crops, because they are more lucrative. The problem is in assuming a level playing field in the market, which it isn't entirely, due to how water is dealt with in CA.
- thephyber 11y agoIt doesn't happen in a vaccuum. There is game theory at work here. Farmers and ranchers don't just use muni water sources. Yes, water is common when you look at the water table, but muni water districts tend to use reservoirs and farmers must use water rights (which are built into the California Constitution, BTW). Nut farmers may be in a position to use more water (I doubt all of them are), but that doesn't mean that all California farmers are able to do the same. California rice farmers, for example, (farming rice in an arid near-desert should almost be a crime) have been netting more money by leasing their water rights than working their crops for years now.[1] [1] http://www.mercurynews.com/drought/ci_26181042/high-bidding-farmers-battle-water-auctions http://www.mercurynews.com/drought/ci_26181042/high-bidding-...
- thrownaway2424 11y agoI don't think it's very fair to call Glenn County a "near-desert". It drains a huge mountain watershed via the Sacramento River and in many places in that county the main hazard to agriculture is the high water table. The depth to water table in the flat part of the county is only 10-20 feet.
- thephyber 11y agoWhen I say "desert", I am talking about the technical definition, which is based off of the amount of precipitation.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoOK, does your private definition of "desert" include a county that averages 20" of rainfall per year and is regularly flooded? Growing rice in arid flood plains has been practiced for a very long time. If you think that Glenn, Butte, and Tehama counties are deserts I strongly urge you to visit them, especially in the early spring. There's just water everywhere.