6 ms·
I'd prefer to skip metric and redefine the foot as the distance light travels in a nanosecond ~ 11.8 inches. The length of the path travelled by light in vacuu
by protomyth 11y ago
I'd prefer to skip metric and redefine the foot as the distance light travels in a nanosecond ~ 11.8 inches. The length of the path travelled by light in vacuum during a time interval of 1/299792458 of a second seems a bit arbitrary to me.
I would also vote for any candidate that would ban anything but powers of 2 in the definition of computer storage.
- 0x0 11y agoYou still have plenty of arbitrary-ness in your definition of a (nano-)second. :)
- protomyth 11y agoI'll take one level over two levels. Besides, memorizing that metric fraction is just wrong. Plus, do we really want to go into space with a unit of measure whose origins are tied to the size of the Earth? Let's at least free part of the definition from an Earth-centric bias. I fear a Mars-centric meter might develop.
- Asbostos 11y agoUnlikely. The metric units have a long history of never having been redefined in a way that breaks previous usage. As far as I'm aware, all redefinitions have just improved the precision, so they don't hurt previous users. Your proposal would make all the old feet wrong and anybody seeing "foot" would have to think about which type of foot it might me.
- protomyth 11y agoOh, I don't know, I bet the future Mars independence movement will try to throw off all the shackles of Earth and switch their units of measure. I jest just a bit, but its not like we humans don't pull stunts like this all the time in the spirit of independence. My proposal is basically the engineering estimate of foot. I would probably name it something different if I were Emperor / Very Powerful Politician. Its small enough to derive the mass and volume units directly.
- kstrauser 11y agoA kibibyte is a fictional unit invented to make computer scientists sound like their lips were still asleep after a dentist visit.
- protomyth 11y agoAll in the service of 10 worshipers. There is a tribe in the US (Yuki) who got it right and counts in octal because they count the spaces in between the fingers (you can hold 8 bottles).
- krylon 11y agoI have tried to convince people to change the metric system to binary, i.e. have a kilogram be 1024 grams, and a kilometer be 1024 meters. Which would finally force hard drive manufacturers to be honest about their devices' capacities. So far, I have not been very successful, though. :(
- protomyth 11y agoI still wonder if you could convince a Congressperson to slip a line in a bill to make the base 2 definition the US Standard.
- gh02t 11y agoIt's not arbitrary at all, it's for backwards compatibility. Previously the meter was defined in terms of the emission lines of krypton-86, which was a distance that we could measure most precisely with an interferometer. Before that it was based on the size of the earth, which could be measured with a astronomical calculations. And originally it was based on the length of a pendulum that produced a period of a 1 seconds, from which the length can be calculated using a scale, a reference mass and a clock (there was another definition, but this one was more precise I believe). Each definition gives you something pretty close to what we now define as a meter, but the precision to which they could be measured at the time differed. The length of a "meter" was more or less the same distance in everybody's mind then as now, but if a 10000 scientists would sit down and perform experiments to actually calculate the exact length in 1700 versus, the mean of the values they reported would be about the same as it is today, but the statistical uncertainty would be much much much higher. The redefining of the meter has typically occurred when some new process was invented that was more precise than the the previous method, for instance today measuring a laser in a vacuum is something like 1/3 the uncertainty than the old method using an interferometer. So the uncertainty is smaller, but crucially the mean value is still basically the same or very close. That's the reason for the weird 1/299792458 seconds, it's because we can define seconds very very precisely (from atomic clocks) and that's the amount of time it takes light in a vacuum to travel the same distance as the previous most precise known value for the length of a meter. If it wasn't done this way, every time we invented a more precise method to measure distance and want to improve the precision of the meter it'd be like defining a whole new unit. Defining a foot as the distance light travels in a nanosecond is fine now, but if we discover an even more precise way to measure distance than a laser in a vacuum we'd end up in the same position, where a "foot" would be some strange fraction of a reference value that makes it work out to agree with the old most precise known value. This sort of stupidly accurate measurement doesn't matter anymore on the day-to-day life scale as the length of a meter is known to within ~(10^-9)%, which is about a ten picometers. However, that means then that if you're fabricating silicon at the nanometer scale, the actual exact length of a nanometer is only known to within about 1% of a nanometer (if I did my math right, might be off by a factor of 10). That's much more significant.
- protomyth 11y ago
- dietrichepp 11y agoI don't get the fascination with powers of two in storage. RAM I understand, because you're counting address lines. But storage? What sense does that make? I have an SD card with 16.0 GB of space available, and I'm recording video at 9.00 Mbit/s. How many hours of footage? Well, (16.0e3 MB) * (8 bit/B) / (9.00 Mbit/s) = 1.42e4 s, or 3.95 hours. Now do the computation with binary units. I have an SD card with 14.9 GiB of space available, and I'm recording video at 9.00 Mbit/s. How many hours of footage? Well, (14.9 GiB) * (1e-6 * 1024^3 MB / GiB) * (8 bit/B) / (9.00 Mbit/s) = ... Why make people do extra math? Shouldn't we choose units that make things easier to calculate, not harder?
- protomyth 11y agoIf its 200Mbytes in RAM, it should be the the same on a disk. Also, a sector is 512bytes of 4096bytes, so the labeling it in powers of 10 actually makes the math worse. Why make people do extra math? Shouldn't we choose units that make things easier to calculate, not harder?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dietrichepp 11y ago> Also, a sector is 512bytes of 4096bytes, so the labeling it in powers of 10 actually makes the math worse. Sector sizes are different between drives anyway. So using sector as a label is just bad practice. And... how does it make the math worse? My hard drive partition has a size of 250140434432 bytes (actual value)... how much is that in GB? Easy, 250.1 GB. For some reason, I was able to do that calculation without the aid of a computer or a calculator. Humans don't count sectors. We like to shift decimal points around. Computers are good at calculation, so we give them the task of multiplying by 512 for us, and displaying measurements in units suitable for human society.
- protomyth 11y ago> Sector sizes are different between drives anyway. Yeah, 512 bytes or, now, 4096 bytes - neither is a power of 10 The math is worse because the computer (address space) and hard drive are actually base 2 and vendors are selling in base 10. This worship of base 10 in every aspect of our lives, even when it doesn't make sense and cheats us out of money, is sad. Computers are base 2, memory is base 2, and storage should be base 2 or else its just a batch of lies. I guess I should be glad the humanity didn't have 11 fingers. The computer is showing you a number, calculating using base 2 will not be any stress on a human since it doesn't show every byte anyway.