2 ms·
OJ Simpson is an odd (but probably not uncommon) case where he could be easily convicted of resisting arrest. So he's in a middle ground where damages from the
by mindslight 11y ago
OJ Simpson is an odd (but probably not uncommon) case where he could be easily convicted of resisting arrest. So he's in a middle ground where damages from the original arrest are unjustified, but damages resulting from his further actions are justified. If he hadn't ran, he could have most likely posted bail.
But I don't see anything fundamentally wrong with reimbursing OJ Simpson for the time of his criminal arrest and imprisonment, especially because that money would have just been used to settle the civil suit. Remember, he was found innocent (no double jeopardy + innocent until proven guilty). We both can say the system got the wrong answer for this case, but insinuations or references to a lower standard of proof don't actually change the verdict.
Step back to a much simpler case of actual innocence. While walking down the street you are randomly arrested and held for a few days before you can post bail. What is the justification for the salary loss from your missed work being your responsibility, rather than the thugs' who caused it?
As far as encouraging judges/juries to find guilty for financial reasons. Do we want to hold back reforms on the fear that our system is so corrupt it will only worsen things? I can certainly see your scenario happening, but the proper course is to then fix those problems rather than give up and keep denying justice to victims of the "justice" system itself.
- sokoloff 11y agoHe was not found innocent. He was found not guilty. The court is not charged with determining the difference and issuing a finding of "innocent". They are only concerned with guilty vs not. Contrast with NFL replay referees, which are for some reason (I assume entertainment/excitement) charged with choosing one of three outcomes: ruling on the field is overturned, ruling on the field stands, and ruling on the field is confirmed. The distinction between the last two is without a difference as to the outcome of the game. I'd much rather 100 guilty persons go free than to wrongly convict a single innocent as a critically important ideal. Any "reform" that has an obvious mechanism that would bias the system to erode that in favor of a lesser benefit is cause for concern for me.
- mindslight 11y ago> They are only concerned with guilty vs not. Yes, because innocence is presumed. When a court finds "not guilty", it is logically equivalent to "innocent". It's not a free pass to say "he was only found not guilty; he's not innocent". > I'd much rather 100 guilty persons go free than to wrongly convict a single innocent as a critically important ideal. Any "reform" that has an obvious mechanism that would bias the system to erode that in favor of a lesser benefit is cause for concern for me. That biased mechanism already exists, although not to the same extent. A judge/jury who can't logically infer guilt would still rather lock up a scumbag, especially if they're likely to repeat offend. A large part of this principle has to be embodied in the judge/jury itself. Not that it should be made worse. I suppose juries could be given leeway over the decision to reimburse, but it would be a larger change to our current system (nothing I've advocated for here is an actual change to the law, just an enforcement of proper civil liability). And you could still end up with the same problem where juries acquit yet routinely don't reimburse because "taxpayers shouldn't pay for someone being at the wrong place". It's less bad than that same person being in prison, but it's still wrong. Cops see "you can beat the rap but you can't beat the ride" as a feature, but everybody who believes in the rule of law should see it as a bug. Of course nothing proposed here would change the fact that the sheer majority of cases plea out due to draconian punishments for nonviolent crimes, and so even long-held legal principles don't end up applying. But the present situation is tough precisely because there are multiple pathologies that all corrupt the justice system away from the fundamental ideals it purports.