4 ms·
DNSSEC is not DANE. All DNSSEC does is prevent MITM injection of DNS packets which is almost certainly one of the techniques QUANTUM INSERT uses. So no surprise
by mike_hearn 11y ago
DNSSEC is not DANE. All DNSSEC does is prevent MITM injection of DNS packets which is almost certainly one of the techniques QUANTUM INSERT uses. So no surprise he thinks DNS should be hardened against it.
And as Chrome experimented with DANE then removed support for it, I don't think you have to worry about that either.
But even if you did - so what? There are CAs in areas controlled by the American and British and French and Chinese governments already. I don't see how it makes anything different.
- tptacek 11y ago1. He's the one who brought up DANE. 2. DNSSEC is harmful for reasons that go past DANE. 3. I am worried about DNSSEC; I think it's a more reasonable thing to be worried about w/r/t/ surveillance than 95% of what's been posted to The Intercept. 4. QUANTUM INSERT will work fine in an all-DNSSEC world. 5. You can revoke a CA. It has happened more than once. You can't revoke a TLD. I'm happy to talk more about how I think DANE CAs are different and worse than the 20391 X509 CAs we have today, but I'm not sure you're asking me to go on at length about that.