3 ms·
Taxing the increase in one's wealth is neither a property tax nor an income tax. The taxable amount would be income minus consumption. The deduction for livin
by logfromblammo 11y ago
Taxing the increase in one's wealth is neither a property tax nor an income tax. The taxable amount would be income minus consumption.
The deduction for living people was intended to account for a reasonable rate of retirement/emergency saving. Corporations don't need to retire, so they don't get it.
- prostoalex 11y ago> The taxable amount would be income minus consumption. Doesn't this result in all sorts of bubbles, as people scramble to manufacture consumption, from real estate to precious metals? Also, taxing the increase seems to benefit wealthy offsprings and trust fund babies in general. For most Americans a change in wealth is also tied up to non-liquid assets, like their house. Let's say you're a retiree living in an area that's been lucky to undergo a real estate boom this specific year. Your house wealth went up 7-10%, yet there's no extra cash flowing in to account for this tax bill, now what? Moreover, with housing being the focal point of wealth accumulation, the government would receive its tax revenue when the things are up in economic cycle, but come the first recession/correction, and not only there are problems with the economy, the source of government revenues has dried up as well.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf you buy gold, you have the gold as an asset. If you buy real estate, you have the property as an asset. That's not consumption. If you buy a steak and eat it, that's consumption. You no longer have the steak, and the butcher doesn't owe you anything else. To avoid stupid government accounting rules, the value of assets would have to be fixed at what you paid for them until they are sold in an arm's-length sale on the open market. So if you're a retiree and you never sell your home, you would not be taxed on its increase in value. There would probably be something made available like a less-parasitic version of a reverse mortgage, to absorb increases in value gradually, so that it could work with the annual real person deduction.
- prostoalex 11y agoThat seems reasonable, and it's how capital gains tax works at least in the US.