4 ms·
I grant you that. But this is the beginning. One obvious question, why aren't more subways fully automated? It's not like they can't implement remote control
by mc32 11y ago
I grant you that. But this is the beginning.
One obvious question, why aren't more subways fully automated? It's not like they can't implement remote control override for emergency situations... Is it still a psychological issue (with riders)?
- marak830 11y agoId say yes, it is entirely psycological, it should be doable now.
- atroyn 11y agoBecause most subways run on legacy infrastructure that would be difficult to upgrade/replace. RF repeaters for emergency remote control for example would need to be installed, certified and thoroughly tested. Given that drivers aren't a big cost centre for subway operations in comparison to maintenance etc. the cost/benefit doesn't make sense.
- mc32 11y agoI think the pensions are a sizable part of their expenses. If they automate their retired workforce age out and there is no endless retirement pool to contribute to. So this would be a significant savings.
- pedalpete 11y agoThey will be. I was thinking of this earlier today, and there is still some coordination between schedules, doors closing with people still trying to get on, etc. etc. In Sydney, you still have people blowing whistles to signal to the driver that it is safe to close the door and go. I'm wondering if that is maybe a more difficult problem to solve than driving. In driving, you know the direction cars 'should' be going, you need to account for lane changes and turns, etc. but for the most part they are expected. I think in an open environment people are much less predictable in their movements. Thoughts?
- crocal 11y agoIn metro systems, 50 percent of service affecting failures come from passenger exchange. Majority of the remaining failure come from vehicle failures. Failures due to driving mistakes are very few. Passenger flow management is the hard part of automated mass transit for performance. It has to be safe yet efficient. It's indeed surprisingly difficult.
- mc32 11y agoBut there are a few fully automated lines. The Taipei brown line is fully automated, granted its not the highest volume line, but still very busy.
- Rexxar 11y agoAutomatic new line are easy but it's harder to automatize old line without interrupting traffic. It has been done for line 1 in Paris between 2007 and 2011 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_M%C3%A9tro_Line_1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paris_M%C3%A9tro_Line_1) but all other old line in Paris have still not been automatized.
- Animats 11y agoThe first fully automated subway line was in New York, in 1959. The Times Square - Grand Central shuttle was fully automated for six years.[1] But, per union rules, they still had someone on board. A major platform fire at the 42nd St station damaged the rolling stock, and when the station was rebuilt, the one-off automated system was not rebuilt. The main reason for trying it on that line is that the trip is very short, and the train reverses at each end. The train operator's walk though the train to get to the other end caused delays. Paying for two drivers, one at each end, was a bit much. [1] http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/IRT_Times_Square-Grand_Central_Shuttle http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/IRT_Times_Square-Grand_Central...