3 ms·
Your GE defense doesn't mean much without referencing the tall pile of pages from the tax code that redefine the dictionary meaning of "loss" to a specific set
by logfromblammo 11y ago
Your GE defense doesn't mean much without referencing the tall pile of pages from the tax code that redefine the dictionary meaning of "loss" to a specific set of circumstances that a business can satisfy via accounting tricks.
GE pays less in taxes because they employ a legion of experts that know the code and can follow the proper rituals. They are not taxed proportionally to their ability to pay, or the degree to which they enjoy the benefits of a well-funded government, but proportionally to their ignorance of the tax code. They know it well, so they pay relatively little in taxes. They are acting appropriately in the interests of their business in light of the circumstances they face. It isn't GE's fault that they can legally pay so little. Nor should we shame them for doing so. They are merely an illustrative example that the US corporate tax code is broken beyond any reasonable expectation of repair.
The "fair share" of taxes is zero. All taxation is inherently unfair, as a violation of one's right to property. The unfairness is [sometimes] justified by spending the tax revenue upon preservation of the commons and projects that serve the common good. But collection is more often motivated by whether it can be done rather than whether it should be done. There is no absolutely fair way to levy a tax, but some taxes are still more unfair than others.
Taxation is not necessarily similar to punishment. It is merely an economic discouragement, with an unavoidable deadweight loss from economic distortion. The net effect is largely the same. People avoid doing the thing that triggers the tax, because the tax makes it more costly or less beneficial.
Income taxes and sales taxes punish useful commerce. Property taxes punish land improvements. Liquor taxes punish recreational drug use. Poll taxes punish being black in the South. Congestion taxes punish driving downtown at the wrong time. Recreation taxes punish having fun in Chicago. Hotel room taxes punish tourism.
So what behaviors would everyone want to discourage by levying a tax? Which of those could actually yield a significant amount of revenue? Those would be the "fairer" taxes.
I'm not sure why you're talking about the top 10% at all. The breakdown of who pays the most is not relevant to what I was saying.