5 ms·
For Evolving Brains, a ‘Paleo’ Diet Full of Carbs
- sytelus 11y agoThis is big slap on paleo movement. People have often complained having "sluggishness" in their thinking process and performing challenging brain activities while on strict paleo diet. Our brain thrives on carbs and it is the fuel that powers it so the results are not entirely a surprise. As usual, the lesson is that neither extremes are usually not a good place to be: Too much carbs or too much proteins, both are bad choices.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoMy days were a lot less productive when I ate a lot of carbs. I spent about half the day sleepy or starving, unable to really think at those times.
- Mithaldu 11y agoBecause you were on the wrong end of the spectrum (and probably eating the wrong carbs too!). The message here is: Everything is needed, in moderation.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoSugar is not, and it did not exist for practical purposes for average people before the 20th century.
- dogma1138 11y agoEat a balanced diet and exercise it's really not rocket science, people are spending way too much time and money on trying to hack their life style. Run/Walk 5-10KM a day, do some anaerobic 2-3 times a week and don't eat total crap... OFC when you eat 1000 cal meals you are going to have a huge sugar drop doesn't matter if it's a huge steak or whole cake. People also waste too much time on controlling caloric intake over way too short periods if you can't control you weekday intake to the required levels just lay down on it during the weekend and you'll still be fine. All these diet's are really a waste of time and money, eat on a regular schedule (never eat when you are starving, as in never get to the point of feeling real hunger), have a diverse diet, try to expand your meals to as many a day as possible, heck I've seen people losing pounds in a heart beat by doing things as simple as droping 1 item from their lunch or moving it to an afternoon snack...
- loopdoend 11y agoAnecdotes aside, steak won't spike your insulin.
- dogma1138 11y ago50-60% of the absorbed your protein intake is metabolized into glucose. Not to mention that people don't tend to eat the leanest cut available so all of those T-Bones and Rib-Eye's add a huge chunk of saturated fat into the mix and that's without all the addons like that nice sour cream and peppercorn sauce with those nice roasted potatos.... Consuming large portions of meat will increase your BG level's they won't spike as fast as if you would chuck down a bowl of ice cream but they'll rise quite well and crash just as quickly later...
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoWell, because meat provides other calories than sugar the crash is 'buffered', right?
- mixmastamyk 11y agoAnd it takes a long time to do so, so the spike will not come like it does with sugar.
- ScottBurson 11y agoActually it does. Insulin also stimulates muscle cells to absorb amino acids. A large protein meal causes quite a substantial insulin response. Ref.: http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/66/5/1264.abstract http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/66/5/1264.abstract
- mixmastamyk 11y agoSee glycemic/insulin indexes.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- nkozyra 11y agoI thought the paleo diet was a relatively balanced diet based on foods thought to be consumed at the time. That would include a good amount of meat and a good amount of harvested vegetables and fruits and no processed grains. There should be plenty of carbohydrates, fat and protein in a diet like that.
- colordrops 11y agoA "slap" is too strong of a word. People have been aware that we've continued to evolve since the paleo era and some of us have better ability to digest grains and dairy than others. A popular diet right now is the Whole 30, which is similar to paleo diets but allows tubers. This research isn't some M. Night Shyamalan twist that has thrown everyone off. It's really up to the individual to listen to their body and do some research and figure out what works best for them.
- magic_beans 11y agoWhat I don't understand is why the Paleo diet doesn't include a mandatory fasting period. Because lord knows our cave-dwelling ancestors were not getting three full meals a day. Intermittent fasting is also known to improve longevity.
- saryant 11y agoIntermittent fasting is popular in parts of the Paleo community: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/health-benefits-of-intermittent-fasting/ http://www.marksdailyapple.com/health-benefits-of-intermitte...
- anonbanker 11y agoBest I've ever felt (and clearest I've ever thought) was on a paleo diet. So how much is a personal anecdote worth against a third-party anecdote?
- Darmani 11y agoMost of paleo is just understanding the science of how our food affects us at a level beyond the nutrition label. It evolves as new evidence comes in, so this can't be a slap against paleo any more than measuring the gravitational constant can be a slap against physics. If you've got the idea that it's about trying to emulate cavemen -- well, there are a couple loudmouths who add the historical reenactment angle, but that's not how most paleo people think. We've known for a long time that potato consumption is ancient. The things that actually matter, and that the paleo-sphere actually talks about, are things like how harmful the glycoalkoids in the skin are. Here's an article discussing the actual Paleo opinion on potatoes: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/potatoes-healthy/#axzz3ikd0khZP http://www.marksdailyapple.com/potatoes-healthy/#axzz3ikd0kh... . In short: they're okay for some people, but avoid the skins.
- enra 11y agoI don't think paleo was never a strict low-carb high-protein diet like Atkins. Obviously people's definition and how they follow the diet varies, but I think first and foremost paleo is about avoiding processed foods, sugar, certain newer foods like grains and dairy, moderating high-starch foods (which have less nutrients), and mostly eating vegetables, meats and fat.
- saryant 11y agoLow-carb can definitely be a subset of Paleo but you're right, Paleo by itself is not strictly low-carb, the carbs you do consume will just be from fruits, vegetables and starches rather than grains and processed foods. I lost 40 pounds on Paleo/Primal sticking to 50-80g carbs/day.
- abledon 11y agoI read a bunch of articles from John Douillard, and he likes to say hunter gatherers were really hunter diggers. They mostly dug up tubers and ate those. You had to be the luckiest caveperson alive to be able to eat ham every morning.
- joshuapants 11y ago> I read a bunch of articles from John Douillard > John Douillard DC is an Ayurvedic Practitioner Maybe I'm weird, but I like my authoritative positions on human evolution to come from evolutionary biologists, not woo-peddlers. At any rate, humans can eat a very diverse range of foods. Inuits eat a primarily animal-derived diet, supplemented with a meager amount of gathered plants during a small portion of the year. Then the spectrum moves all the way over to peoples that eat mostly plant-matter with few animal products. Humans adapt wonderfully, that's why we're so prolific. There is no magic diet that happens to be "right."
- coldtea 11y agoActually we don't adapt so wonderfully. And historical times is not enough time to properly adapt evolutionary-wise. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/81/2/341.full http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/81/2/341.full
- dang 11y ago> woo-peddlers Please don't do this here. "When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- itistoday2 11y agoI am grateful to everyone who has helped me expand my thinking beyond myself when it comes to dietary choices. Whether or not the latest diet fad says X is good for me, I now think about how consuming X affects not just me, but the environment, and the X.
- cconroy 11y agoOne thing is clear: our brains required tremendous amounts of energy. Cooking starches allows us to extract more energy from them. Meat eating is calorically dense too and so that could of played a role (see Expesive Tissue Hypothesis). I have read meat-eating was hugley beneficial during resource scarcity. The critical question is what diet do we thrive on? A carb rich plant-based diet is my guess based mostly on Dr. Michael Greger's work on summarizing nutrition science literature [0]. But I shall be convinced otherwise if the science is there. [0] http://nutritionfacts.org/ http://nutritionfacts.org/
- monting 11y agoThis article is completely off the mark about the paleo diet. Paleo is not necessarily low carb - usually about 20%~40% of calories are from carbs. Tubers like sweet potatoes are specifically recommended in paleo regimens. The author is confusing Paleo with Atkins/ketogenic diets.
- nazgulnarsil 11y agoWe've made resistant starch a big art of what we optimize for in MealSquares because there are 30 years of studies showing health benefits and the mainstream just never seems to have gotten the memo. Resistant starch is starch you can't digest but your gut bacteria can. When RS2 is heated and then cooled it forms into RS3, which seems to be the most beneficial version. Mostly from oats, though we have experimented with cassava (the starchy root used to make tapioca).
- OnleMeMeMe 11y agoI'm open to everything that is proven by trials. Everything else is opinion.
- XzetaU8 11y ago"A New Human Trial Undermines the Carbohydrate-insulin Hypothesis of Obesity, Again" http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.gr/2015/08/a-new-human-trial-seriously-undermines.html http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.gr/2015/08/a-new-human-tri...
- fasteo 11y agoThere is a very simple rule I use for this; not sure how accurate it is, but it works well for me. - Protein - meat - is for repairing/building - Carbs are for fueling - Fats are somewhere in between. Cells membranes are basically fat and fat is also a very clean,dense and "slow" form of energy. Based on your activity level: - Couch potato: Eat very low carb (basically no starches, under 50g per day). - Light activity: Eat low carb (under 100g per day). - Moderate activity: Eat moderate carbs (under 200g per day). I am here, weight training 3 times per week, with 2-3 long walks (about an hour) - High activity: Eat high carb (>200g per day) - Eat between 1 and 1,5 g/protein per kilo. - Adjust fat to achieve your desired calorie intake. For most of us, between 2.000 and 2.5000 kcals/day is a good target. The key here is to stop demonizing carbs/fats and recognize that they have its place in our diet. I have also observed that, regardless of your activity level, starting low-carb when you are obese is a good thing to do, but after 1-2 years, low-carbs diets go against you.