5 ms·
The only real solution to this is to stop externalizing the cost of false positives onto the victims. Kidnap someone and put them in a cage for a month so they
by mindslight 11y ago
The only real solution to this is to stop externalizing the cost of false positives onto the victims.
Kidnap someone and put them in a cage for a month so they lose their salary, job, apartment etc? That adds up to an awful lot of easily demonstrable financial damage that the justice system is directly responsible for. Only when false arrests and prosecution start directly impacting these organizations' budgets will they possibly care about the harm they do.
- alentrekin 11y agosee also, section III http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/opa/press-releases/attachments/2015/03/04/ferguson_police_department_report.pdf http://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/opa/press-release...
- alentrekin 11y agoPolice privilege provides legal justification for any detention made with probable cause. Heroin straw > arrest > detention under bail.
- gknoy 11y agoIn the case mentioned in the article, though, when the man is _holding_ a soda, and has said that he's going to use the straw for that, it seems farcical to consider treating the straw as drug paraphernalia as "probable cause".
- tsotha 11y agoProbable cause is something you need to conduct a search. They went far beyond a search in this instance. I'm still trying to wrap my mind around the idea they actually charged him with a crime when they had no evidence a crime was committed. None. I don't understand why the judge didn't laugh them out of court.
- spacemanmatt 11y agoBecause he's racist, corrupt, or both?
- tsotha 11y agoOr neither. You probably shouldn't make allegations like that without having some kind of evidence.
- spacemanmatt 11y agoCharged with a crime absent evidence of a crime is evidence of corruption. The racism is merely speculation but it's not wild speculation. You shouldn't overlook obvious evidence.
- jackgavigan 11y agoGoing after budgets won't really bring about meaningful change. You'd need to go after the individuals. In a circumstance like that described in the article, it would not be unreasonable to investigate the police officers' actions, specially the question of whether he truly had reasonable grounds for suspicion that the straw was truly drug paraphernalia. If not, prosecute him for assault, kidnapping, false imprisonment, etc. I know it's never going to happen but one can dream...
- outworlder 11y ago> If not, prosecute him for assault, kidnapping, false imprisonment, etc. Can one do that? Why doesn't it seem to happen more often?
- nickff 11y agoGovernment prosecutors are generally unwilling to charge police with crimes because they see themselves as being on the same 'team', and the 'blue wall' will stop them. In addition, we should remember that police officers are an arm of the state, not a charitable organization out to help people. There is simply no reason for anyone in the bureaucracy (including the prosecutors' offices) to care about or want to fix these problems.
- LordKano 11y agoPrecisely. Unless an officer's actions are both shockingly egregious and clearly documented, prosecutors usually won't do anything. After that cop is gone, the prosecutor still must work with his friend and colleagues to present cases for trial.
- function_seven 11y ago> Going after budgets won't really bring about meaningful change. Sure it will. If the cost of arresting someone was potentially a few hundred thousand dollars each time, the police would have to be a lot more careful about whom they arrest. Cities and counties would literally be unable to afford to arrest everyone. As far as the rest of your comment is concerned, full agreement here, even regarding the pipe-shapedness of the dream :(