5 ms·
These changes don't sound like they're really addressing the core problem. Here's how things currently work: - Broadcaster sets rates. - Cable company negoti
by Someone1234 11y ago
These changes don't sound like they're really addressing the core problem.
Here's how things currently work:
- Broadcaster sets rates.
- Cable company negotiates and eventually settles (with or without blackouts).
- Cable company bundles these rates with other rates from other channels and passes it on to the consumer.
- Cable company gets the backlash from the consumer as a result of rate hikes.
So as you can likely tell, broadcasters have too much power, because cable companies will ultimately be blamed either for blackouts (failed negotiations) OR for rate hikes. So it puts them in a lose/lose situation.
Instead what cable should be doing is:
- Unbundle channels entirely.
- Pass on rate increases to the consumer for that specific channel.
- Itemise how much of what you pay goes to the broadcaster Vs. the cable company
- Alternatively the cable company could charge $0 on the channels themselves (100% broadcaster) and charge a "delivery fee" or "service fee" on the entire account.
This way the broadcaster gets blamed for the rate hikes directly from consumers, and consumers now have more power to drop certain channels if they feel the value they receive is lower than the cost they pay (e.g. $5/month for Trutv).
That's what the FCC should be doing.
- 300bps 11y agoUnfortunately it is the content providers that have forced bundling onto the cable providers. Verizon FIOS was the first major cable provider though to successfully implement unbundling. As you said, the FCC would do well to restrict forced bundling. http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/17/media/verizon-fios/ http://money.cnn.com/2015/04/17/media/verizon-fios/
- isomorphic 11y agoWhile your point about content providers is well-seen, let's be clear about what we mean by "unbundling." I think the consumer expectation is true a-la-carte, i.e., channel-level granularity in package choice. What Verizon has implemented is packages of bundles of channels, plus a required minimum base package. While this is progress, it is not real a-la-carte. Personally, the add-on fees and mandatory equipment rental accounted for 50% of the nominal price of my FiOS TV bill. Packages would have barely dented this. Therefore I canceled FiOS TV earlier this year. By the time the cable providers actually implement a-la-carte, no one under the age of 40 will be subscribing.
- rhino369 11y agoPeople only think they want truly a-la-carte. The fact that most people don't watch most channels is already built into the system. The average consumer won't save any money because the price of these channels already reflects average viewership. Those who watch a bunch of different channels would pay a lot more. Only those who watch a very small amount of channels would actually save money. But paying for access to a channel doesn't really make sense anymore. Why should anyone care what channel content is broadcast on? Why should someone watching a few hours on two channels pay twice as much compared someone one watched one channel all the time? The later is consuming much more content. Paying by channel is just a shitty way of gauging usage. A la carte will reduce the amount of content without really reducing prices. Every station will essentially be like TNT or TBS. Netflix shows that people want the opposite of a la carte. They want an unlimited plan. It's probably a moot point, video on demand is going to kill cable no matter what.
- astazangasta 11y agoSo continue to offer the bundle as well.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> It's probably a moot point, video on demand is going to kill cable no matter what. Cable is a major channel for video on demand, and the cable companies are also the major ISPs, so VOD is win/win for them anyway (especially if they succeed in challenging the FCC Open Internet rules.) They are going to be "killed" by it the same way that the incumbent wireline telcos were killed by mobile.
- maxerickson 11y agoDo you think they maybe meant the bundle of channel subscriptions?
- nickff 11y agoMy preferences coincide with yours (as I agree the latter option would be better for everyone), but I do not understand why the FCC must impose either solution. Why does the FCC need to get involved in this situation at all? I also don't understand how the FCC will determine whether someone is negotiating in 'good faith', as each party to a negotiation has only two options: give the other party more, or walk away (at least temporarily). Is there another option that I am not aware of that is indicative of 'bad faith'? I'm not even sure whether someone can negotiate in 'bad faith', because if the party that walks away is losing less money from walking away than they would lose by giving more the the counter-party, walking away is the rational choice; if they lose more by walking than by giving in, they are the ones being hurt the most. Regardless of what happens with "cable", it seems to me that 'channels' are gradually unbundling themselves by providing access over the internet, and shows may soon unbundle from channels in a similar fashion. Both of these moves provide content providers more feedback with respect to what the consumers demand, which will benefit the consumers most. Personally, I hope consumers demand space operas.
- jackpirate 11y agoif they lose more by walking than by giving in, they are the ones being hurt the most. That doesn't actually follow. Consider the case of Alice (who owns 1 cow) and Bob (who owns 9 cows). Charlie wants to buy cows, but only if he can get exactly 10 of them. Alice and Bob might negotiate a deal whereby Alice gets 25% of the proceeds and Bob gets 75% despite the fact that Bob is providing 90% of the goods. This is because Bob has significantly more to lose by the deal falling through.
- jegutman 11y agoSo I think this is a good model for consumers, but probably not great from a sales perspective. Think of the broadcasters as charging for "selling" their companies. I hate cable companies, but still worth thinking about why they don't do this presuming intelligence instead of stupidity (referencing good recent AHarris post).
- kuschku 11y ago> good model for consumers, but probably not great from a sales perspective That’s what regulation is for: The only thing we should be concerned about is the consumer, the employee, the normal person. This includes job security, but it also includes allowing a free market in the terms that is necessary. For TV channels, a free market is obviously an advantage, where the user can choose which channels to pay for and which not. (Btw, this is one of the types of business where TTIP will not influence existing EU legislation at all, but only bring today’s EU laws to the US)
- amlgsmsn 11y agoThe cable companies won't do itemizing since they make money off people that don't watch channels they don't watch. Also if you look at the graph in the article, the broadcasting portion of the cable bill is relatively small.
- TallGuyShort 11y agoAlthough as a consumer I would like unbundling, and make it clearer who is responsible for the rate increases, this could have unpredictable consequences to revenue for the cable companies. If the unbundled, I would pay for 2 or 3 channels, whereas I now pay for none. On the other hand, how many people currently pay for a bundle and would also only pay for 2 or 3 channels?
- ghkbrew 11y agoCable companies would just need to make their pricing structure more accurately reflect their cost structure. Comcast could charge me a base "connection" fee which cover's their overhead plus an itemized amount for each channel I subscribe to. Making the cost per channel exactly what they are charged by the network would be a great way to pass consumer pressure back upstream.
- chongli 11y agoThe problem with forcing unbundling is then you'd have a huge number of people paying only for ESPN (which costs a lot of money) and tons of other channels would simply go out of business. Maybe that's a good thing? I don't know, I'm a cord-cutter.
- exelius 11y agoThe entire model of having "channels" is going away. Studios already produce content across multiple genres; "channels" are just their way of organizing those shows into packages to make them easier to show on a linear cable channel. Netflix and Amazon have shown that you can manage a single brand with many genres beneath. There's no need to have channels; we can just have "ABC", "NBC", "Fox", "Scripps", etc. ABC would include ESPN, Disney, and all their other channels; Fox would include FX and whatever else Fox has, etc. It won't happen overnight, but I would expect channels to go away gradually over the next decade.
- dublinben 11y agoAt that point, we won't even have those channel/network brands to the same extent. The independent production studios that actually make the shows will increasingly take their shows directly to Netflix/Amazon/etc.
- exelius 11y agoMost production studios are owned by the networks. Media is a very incestuous business where a group of 7-10 companies own nearly the entire industry. They get away with it because nobody usually owns more than 10-20% of any single company in the next level of the chain. So a production company may be owned by 6 different networks, all of whom bid on which shows they want to pick up for distribution. But in the end, all the money flows to the same people, and the relationships between producers and distributors are where the value in the industry is. Whoever runs the money today (the networks) will continue to do so in the future, because they own the entire supply chain. The people who make a living funding TV shows today will continue to do so regardless of the distribution channel. It's all a shell game :)
- yock 11y agoI think this just exposes how much of an unnecessary middleman cable companies have become.
- cptskippy 11y agoSo is network TV on cable different from the local OTA broadcast? If network TV is free OTA then why do cable companies have to pay to rebroadcast it? Wouldn't in be in the network's best interest to get their broadcasts in front of as many people as possible? It seems like blackouts would just be reducing their ratings numbers and thus reducing what they can charge for ads. What am I missing?
- simcop2387 11y agoFor OTA you're missing a 1992 federal law[1] that requires the cable companies to get licensing for retransmission of those stations. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_Television_Consumer_Protection_and_Competition_Act_of_1992 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_Television_Consumer_Prot...
- dublinben 11y agoCable companies used to just pull in the local feed, and push that out over their network. The local broadcasters called foul, and got Congress to enact a law (1992 Cable Act) that required cable companies to obtain permission to rebroadcast these public signals.[0][1] This quickly resulted in broadcasters charging ever increasing rates to deliver their content to their own viewers. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retransmission_consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retransmission_consent [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_Television_Consumer_Protection_and_Competition_Act_of_1992 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_Television_Consumer_Prot...
- cptskippy 11y agoI guess established Broadcast Networks were afraid of increased competition from Cable TV Networks and got the Retransmission Consent provision added to the Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act because otherwise Cable TV Operators would be able to rebroadcast their stations freely which would only encourage adoption of Cable TV? It was sort of a win win for Broadcast Networks regardless of whether Cable TV succeeded for failed.
- sytelus 11y agoHere's the basic problem with your proposed model: Channels popularity follows power law[1]. If you gave choice to subscribers to pay-by-channel most of the channels will die horrible death in sort period of time. However this is not good for the cable company because lack of content means they will lose portion of subscribers who are in long tail as well as revenue that is generated by long tail. One may argue it's also not good for consumers as the available selection shrinks dramatically. So in essence cable companies are packaging low performers with high performers so that long tail survives. This is one of the situation where "let the market figure out" strategy doesn't work very well either for producers or consumers. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zipf%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zipf%27s_law