4 ms·
I link this in every discussion about how we will never get fusion power: http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/12/04/11/0435231/mit-fusion-researchers-answer-you
by adrianN 11y ago
I link this in every discussion about how we will never get fusion power:
http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/12/04/11/0435231/mit-fusion-researchers-answer-your-questions http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/12/04/11/0435231/mit-fusi...
See the nice funding graph in question three.
If we were to decide that fusion is the way to go and would fund it appropriately, we could get commercial reactors much faster.
However, note that building power plants takes a lot of time. Building a new nuclear power plant for example takes 6-8 years just for the actual construction. Planning and bureaucracy have to be added to this. So even if we speed up fusion power development so that we can start building commercial fusion power plants in say twenty years, that's still mostly too late if we want to limit warming to two degrees.
At current CO2 production rates we have time until 2039 for that.
http://trillionthtonne.org/ http://trillionthtonne.org/
- adwn 11y ago> See the nice funding graph in question three. Oh please, that graph is dug out whenever the feasibility of fusion is discussed. It's a prediction from 1976 – you should know how credible decade-long predictions on the progress of unproven technologies are. It's also pure fantasy that if we just throw enough money at the problem, we'll get the work done quickly. That's not even the case for large software projects, so how do you expect that to work for a task with so many hard scientific and engineering challenges?
- tormeh 11y agoImagine that instead of writing "javac file.java" every time you wanted to recompile you had to hire workers and buy materials to build the program using cogs and levers. Development would obviously slow down a lot if you had to ration your recompiles because of funding. Also, a project has an optimal amount of employees. I'm pretty sure ITER and the like has less than that number right now. Throwing money at the problem seems like an excellent way to speed things up.
- adrianN 11y agoBesides the obvious problems of building very expensive machines like ITER with a limited budget, there are multiple routes that might lead to commercial fusion. Magnetic confinement is just one of them. Currently it's the only one that gets any significant funding. If we had unlimited money we could pursue all options simultaneously. That's how it worked in the Manhattan Project. They tried all ways to a working nuke in parallel. So they came up with Little Boy (gun type assembly) and Fat Man (implosion type assembly).