4 ms·
More accurately, it draws into question the accuracy of tree-ring measurements as a proxy for temperature. We do not have a situation "where plant behavior clo
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
More accurately, it draws into question the accuracy of tree-ring measurements as a proxy for temperature.
We do not have a situation "where plant behavior closely follows other measurements of the climate for a very long time". Instead we have a situation where one of the principle components of a small subset of tree-ring data generally follows other measurements of the climate for a very short time. And where even with all of that we still have "divergence" problems. These problems draw into question the validity of such measurements as a proxy for historical climate. If they do not track global temperature even a little accurately today how can we have any confidence that they do so in times long past when we don't have temperature records to check their accuracy?
The answer is that we don't. And every indication seems to be that many of these proxy reconstructions from the CRU are wholly inaccurate representations of historical climate.