4 ms·
I have spent some hundreds of hours listening to arguments for global warming, er Catastrophic Anthropogenic Climate Change or AGW or ACC (or whatever the PC ac
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
I have spent some hundreds of hours listening to arguments for global warming, er Catastrophic Anthropogenic Climate Change or AGW or ACC (or whatever the PC acronym is this week)
The problem that I keep getting back to is best phrased like this: archaeological climate record extrapolation is nowhere near as sure-fire as supporters make it out to be. I have many more problems, but this one addresses the current article.
I understand these are honest, hard-working scientists, and they know a heckuva lot more than I do about their particular area, but as an intelligent person I can make fairly informed guesses based on the standards of proof required and the types of phrases being used. There a lot of "it appears" and "it seems" in there, phrases that mean that while consensus has been achieved (we'll take that as a given for this comment) it's nowhere near a slam-dunk. There's also quite a bit of ad-hominem character assassination going on, even in this piece. I find that folks who have to result to labeling and name-calling usually are insecure about their position.
Especially troubling is the way the current divergence is addressed. The argument looks to me like "we can use this data as a proxy for all periods except those where we have direct measurements to verify correlation" I find that weak at best.
To me, the layman, tree-ring data is going to show you how well a certain tree grew in a certain place over time. That might or might not have implications for the larger area or the entire planet. Like so many other pieces of this argument, it depends on having a control group and repeatable experiments -- none of which are doable. So it boils down to speculation. Speculation by great, intelligent people, perhaps, but speculation nonetheless.
I know some folks will say "no matter what the proof you're never going to believe" I don't know how to respond to that, except to point out that I've always been more interested in the character of the debate around GW and the political implications of letting scientific consensus drive public policy more than I have the actual facts on the ground. I have no more emotion invested in whether the planet is cooling or warming than I do variations of the gravitational constant around the time of the big bang. Whichever way the facts lead will not change my underlying concern. So I really don't have a dog in this fight as far as the science goes, at least not to the degree that some others do.
- algorias 17y agoThis bothers me too. I don't know how tree-ring data is interpreted, but it's safe to assume that it's not a simple size of rings -> temperature mapping. How are the myriad of factors that contribute to tree growth accounted for?
- InclinedPlane 17y agoHow are the myriad of factors that contribute to tree growth accounted for? The short answer is that they are not, because they are not known. That's the point. If they were known there wouldn't be nearly so much controversy. Climate history modelling using tree-ring data as a proxy is incredibly immature. It may have value but the degree to which it has been relied upon is all out of proportion to the validity of the current state of the science (which is probably true for much of climate science at the moment as well).
- lisper 17y ago> Especially troubling is the way the current divergence is addressed. The argument looks to me like "we can use this data as a proxy for all periods except those where we have direct measurements to verify correlation" I find that weak at best. +1 Yes, I know that "+1" a weak comment. But I wanted to draw attention to this particular point because I think it's really crucial, and so far I have not seen it well addressed.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI'll try to say it with some more detail. Let's assume you have a sample from trees in one forest in say, Siberia, going back five thousand years. Do you know all of the environmental factors and how they've changed over that time period? Or do you just know how well the trees grew? Assuming somehow you did know all of the environmental factors. Can you say with certainty how each of them affected ring width? Or are you relying on some sort of statistical correlation (which may be useful, but is NOT the same as causation)? Let's assume that you know the micro-climate details and have established a very strong correlation between input factors and ring growth. With multiple or hundreds of factors I find that hard to swallow but let's say you did it. Now tell me, how many forests just like that do you need to sample to have some overall picture of global climate? Ten? A hundred? Does the data even exist in the numbers required? And how would you calculate the number required? It seems to me in order to be able to determine sample size you'd have to have a pretty good model of how the climate operated to begin with. And since this is the thing to be demonstrated, you can't also have this as a given -- that's circular logic. As I understand the response to this, it relies heavily on statistical measurements and such. That's all fine and dandy, but it's a qualitatively different type of discussion than a theory-experiment-verify discussion. It's much more like a epidemiological study. And these are notorious for meaning much different things than researchers want them to. When all's said and done the only thing you may be proving is the statistical likelihood that certain trees will grow certain ways over the next few decades. Or you may have spent a lot of time proving or demonstrating nothing of any value at all, unfortunately.
- logjam 17y ago>The problem is....archaelogical climage record extrapolation is nowhere as sure fire.... Then pray provide us with some science supporting your point. If you cannot, when you just keep bleating you are "troubled" over and over, you really look like someone just pushing an agenda without any support whatsoever. And oh, what's needed now is a "slam-dunk" on the issue. A "slam-dunk", of course, was never needed when any of the corporate interests (who are the ones really astroturfing and dissembling on this issue) set out to basically rape ecosystems for their stockholders. Do you also call for "slam-dunks" from these corporate interests, or just when it's convenient for your political ideology? This whole discussion is reminiscent of the tobacco industries continual two-faced insistence on "slam-dunks" when it came to any encroachment on their ability to reap profit from suffering. >I have no more emotion invested in whether the planet is cooling or warming than I do variations of the gravitational constant around the time of the big bang. Whichever way the facts lead will not change my underlying concern. So I really don't have a dog in this fight as far as the science goes, at least not to the degree that some others do. Right. And in your disinterestedness you personally posted three anti-warming editorials to Hacker News over the last three weeks. Not three science articles - three editorials espousing a single view.
- gloob 17y agoParanoia and ad hominem don't do your argument much good.
- aquateen 17y agoWhere is the ad hominem?
- logjam 17y agoOh. Asking for someone to actually back up their emotional little assertions with facts, and pointing out the hypocrisy of the obvious axe-grinding which accompanies their fervent assertions that they are unbiased is...."paranoia and ad hominem". And your response was to add nothing except labeling "paranoia", right? Was that before or after you mentioned "ad hominem". Or did you, like him, have any actual science to cite here to support his assertions? Your projection doesn't do your argument much good. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_projection http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Psychological_projection
- nfnaaron 17y ago"There's also quite a bit of ad-hominem character assassination going on, even in this piece. I find that folks who have to result to labeling and name-calling usually are insecure about their position." Yes, the amount of derision, even targeting scientists who merely hold an opposing interpretation of the data, is troubling.
- gjm11 17y agoMany biologists, palaeontologists, etc., apply "labeling and name-calling" to creationists; the person whose blog the original article here is posted on (not, as it happens, the author of the article itself) is a good example. I do not find it plausible that the reason for this is that those biologists are "insecure about their position". So another explanation for the ad hominems remarked on here would seem to be: many climate scientists think that denying AGW is about as sensible as denying evolution. For what it's worth, this seems to me a more likely explanation than that they're "insecure about their position". Incidentally, there's not exactly been a shortage of ad hominem attacks going the other way. My impression, of which I'm not particularly confident, is that the density of personal attacks on opponents is higher in the output of AGW disbelievers than in that of AGW believers.
- thwarted 17y agoI know some folks will say "no matter what the proof you're never going to believe" If there was proof, you wouldn't need to believe. Anyone who says "you're never going to believe" isn't looking to convince anyone, they're looking for others to have blind faith in order to have their own faith validated.