6 ms·
Some thoughts: The price point is impressive if you can sell at only ~$50 more than a standard lead-acid battery. If pressed to find a flaw, I think the bigge
by CamperBob2 11y ago
Some thoughts:
The price point is impressive if you can sell at only ~$50 more than a standard lead-acid battery. If pressed to find a flaw, I think the biggest is one you've already identified:
There’s one: you can’t run your lights and/or stereo as
long with your engine turned off. Ohm’s battery reserve
comes in at 10 amp hours; most lead-acid car batteries
come in at about 45 amp hours. If you can run your
stereo with your engine off for three hours on your
current battery, you’d be able to run it on Ohm for less
than an hour.
Nobody with a modern car or SUV is going to get three hours' runtime for their accessory equipment. With the original equipment (AGM lead acid, 70 AH/450 CCA) battery in my two-seat passenger car, I'm lucky to get 15 minutes' worth of stereo/nav/etc. operation with the ignition off. There's no conceivable way that 10 AH is enough for this application. The more "luxurious" the car, and the newer it is, the worse this problem will be. Meanwhile, LiFePO4 battery cost will probably go in the opposite direction, leaving room for competitors to offer more power for less money.
So I'd reconsider the size of the LiFePO4 battery, even if it makes the product cost a bit more. You need those high-end buyers. You're not going to sell these to Joe Sixpack for installation in his '98 F-150 pickup.
And yes, your marketing materials are grossly exaggerating both the environmental problems with lead-acid batteries and their typical service life. There is clearly a global regulatory jihad against lead in all of its forms and uses, though, so you do have that going for you.
Edit: Don't forget that auto stop/start is growing in popularity as well. I think it's actually mandatory in some (European?) markets. OEMs are moving toward "smarter" (read: DRM-locked) batteries to handle these additional requirements. I wonder if a better business model might be to offer recycling/rebuilding services that swap out lead plates for LiFePO4/supercap hardware in existing batteries?
- heywire 11y ago>Nobody with a modern car or SUV is going to get three hours' runtime for their accessory equipment. Really? I've left the satellite radio playing for hours in my 2011 Hyundai Sonata at moderate volume with no hint of problem starting my car afterwards. It has the premium sound system (including subwoofer) and navigation.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThere are always going to be anecdotes to the contrary, but the trend is pretty clearly in the opposite direction. Usually what happens in my case is I forget to turn the headlights from 'Auto' to 'Off.' But even with the lights and fans off I don't tend to see more than 20-30 minutes of operation at most. The car's version of HAL 9000 tries to be conservative and shut things down as soon as the battery voltage goes below about 11.9.
- micaeked 11y agoThat's also anecdotal.
- CamperBob2 11y agoNo, that's a repeatable observation. There's a difference. Look, take it up with Volkswagen AG. They're the ones who designed the electrical system in the car in question. Don't shoot the messenger, but a long term business plan centered around aftermarket car batteries is going to be a challenging play, for these and other reasons.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ars 11y agoHeadlight != radio. The headlights can be easily 150watt. I doubt the radio uses more than 15.
- conjecTech 11y agoThose numbers are dead on. Just measured them the other day.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAre led headlights a similar draw?
- VLM 11y agoYou're probably getting downvoted because a c*4 discharge rate implies over 3 kilowatts continuous draw, which is rather unlikely. Probably your battery is near dead. Also F150 pickup trucks are about $60K when loaded with options. Those guys are free spenders compared to commuter car drivers.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThat's not how it works. By design, there is still plenty of capacity left in the battery when the car's computer shuts down the accessories. The accessory draw is enough to lower the (indicated) terminal voltage from about 12.6 volts to about 12.0 in 15-30 minutes, depending on what accessories are actually turned on.
- rm-rfU 11y agoMy car has a timer that shuts things down after 15min (or so). Regardless of battery voltage.
- yellowapple 11y ago> Also F150 pickup trucks are about $60K when loaded with options. If you buy new. The parent commenter specifically mentioned a '98 F150. Personally, though, I'm interested in one of these for my Blazer for the cold-temperature performance alone. If the lower power capacity is an issue, I could always just carry around my jumpbox.
- paulmd 11y agoI can't emphasize how wrong you are about the whole "you can only get 15 minutes of radio off a car battery". Your battery is broken or you have a near-short somewhere. I sit in my cheap-ass Jeep for 45 minutes a week listening to the radio for 5 times a week and have for years. Replace it, if it doesn't work seek professional repair.
- CamperBob2 11y agoAmusingly, I also have a cheap-ass Jeep, and gee, you're right, it has no problem running the radio for at least an hour with the ignition off. So if you think this is a sustainable, scalable state of affairs, at a time when automotive tech is undergoing its greatest disruption since the horse, we'll leave the discussion at that. I'll just say that I think this is a really bad time to aim their business plan at a fixed target, and one that I'm not sure they actually understand.
- paulmd 11y agoI wasn't putting a dog in this race with that comment, just urging you to get that battery checked up on before it dumped you at the side of the road. Headlights pull some wattage, but a radio really shouldn't and there's no way 15 minutes should cause any concerning symptoms. Just trying to help :) I'm not sure how I feel about it, personally. I share a lot of the concerns that have been raised here (battery cutout wiping my clock+radio, vibration, longevity, cranking+jumping ability, etc), and I'm always a bit wary of "One Weird Trick; Auto Companies Hate Him!" claims. I'm certainly not going to be the test dummy for that one, I got places to be that aren't the side of the road. Give me 5 years of early adopters and we'll see. Neither here nor there, but I was one of the early adopters of electric motors in R/C airplanes. I was doing it since before brushless was a thing (about 15 years), my first plane used a brushed Graupner car motor and Sub-C car packs (boy howdy was that underpowered). I can tell you that batteries have a very finite lifetime, especially when you abuse them under high-current loads. I worry that a lot of hybrid/electric owners are in for some sticker shock when their packs wear out. That one unit is a pretty significant fraction of the total cost and it's a wear item. I know there's steps taken to lengthen the life of the pack, but you can't run them indefinitely.