4 ms·
Because otherwise people would have realized much earlier that their tree-ring data is not a useful proxy for temperature?
by hga 17y ago
Because otherwise people would have realized much earlier that their tree-ring data is not a useful proxy for temperature?
- bjelkeman-again 17y agoDo you have a good peer-reviewed article that shows that tree-ring data as a proxy for temperature is a poor fit. I'd be interested in reading it.
- hga 17y agoa) One of the worst aspects of ClimateGate is how that group was keeping people less fervent than them out of the peer-reviewed literature. b) All you have to do is look at how their tree-ring data (MXD to be precise) diverges from recorded temperatures starting in 1960, it declines, to be precise, to know why they felt they had to "hide the decline". Heck, look at the chart where they cut off the green line that represents this data just as it's starting to fall and conveniently where it's in a thicket of other lines so that you won't easily notice the cutoff.
- robotrout 17y agoI don't have one. That's sort of the problem, though, isn't it? With the climatologists interfering so strongly in the way this is supposed to work, by selecting which peers do their reviews, and by applying political pressure to the journals, the whole "look it up in the established body of work" approach has been sabotaged. EDIT: I forgot an important one. The collusion aspect that the emails revealed. We're not going to put this result in our paper, even though we believe it, because it messes up Scientist B's premise.
- thaumaturgy 17y agoYou're kidding, right? Evidence of absence is not proof. Imagine if this argument were used in other contexts: "there are no papers published in peer-reviewed journals about intelligent design. This proves that there's a conspiracy in the biological community!" In fact: there are a few published papers which challenge popular climatological measurements and papers, and they are cited as often as possible by ... I don't want to call them denialists, but I'm not sure what else to call them. So, wrong on both counts.
- robotrout 17y agoReread my post. I didn't say that the absence of papers proved anything. I said that the scientific process has been sabotaged in this instance, making things more unclear than they should be. You are slick though! EDIT: Perhaps you're honestly confused. I'm a bit doubtful on that, but in case you are. We know that the process has been sabotaged. Not because there are no papers, but because many of the details of the sabotage were revealed in the ClimateGate emails.
- thaumaturgy 17y agoYou seem to be another carrier of the recent disease infecting HN, where users are commenting on articles that they didn't bother reading.
- hga 17y agoPray tell, how do you know I didn't read it? (In all fairness, I read some, skimmed the rest.)
- thaumaturgy 17y agoThanks (sincerely) for being honest about that, at least. There were two clues: one, your comment timestamp was not far removed from the time that the article was posted. I read pretty quickly, but it still took me some time to fully read and digest the entire article. Second, there was your statement: "their tree-ring data is not a useful proxy for temperature". The article specifically mentioned that tree-ring data correlated with other proxies for temperature measurements, as well as going into other details (like the difference between measuring ring thickness and ring density, and the fact that there has only somewhat recently been a divergence between the measurements). Basically, the article answered your statement, I think.
- hga 17y agoNo, it doesn't answer why they felt they had to "hide the decline" instead of discussing and justifying how the recent divergence is congruent with their claims of its usefulness as a proxy when there were no (accurate) temperature readings. These are not the actions of honest men.
- ugh 17y agoWell, they discussed it. In public. In peer reviewed journals. You know, this mail is not the only place where climate scientists talked about tree rings.
- 17y ago