4 ms·
Vernor Vinge also made the observation, that if most civilizations undergo an exponential increase in technological and societal progress, they're likely to dis
by stcredzero 11y ago
Vernor Vinge also made the observation, that if most civilizations undergo an exponential increase in technological and societal progress, they're likely to disappear within a dozen generations after inventing radio. I'm not so sure we can reasonably imagine the signature of a civilization "subliming" to put it in Iain M. Bank's "Culture" terms.
So if the likeliest outcomes of industrial civilization are environmental self-destruct, self immolation in war, or "subliming" to something we can't imagine, then this would handily explain the Fermi paradox.
- trhway 11y agowe know that we can't "see" most of the Universe - the dark matter/energy. That pretty much can happen to be the real Universe, and we're just living in the part set aside for the non-intelligent species. It is like being an ant on Earth - there is a planetary tech civilization being developed while you have no idea what is going around. The only interaction you my have with the civilization - if you're lucky, and you are some kind of special ants, then your colony may get moved before dam valley to be flooded, otherwise - not even that...
- jerf 11y agoGiven that A: dark matter has to have been around since the beginning to solve the problems it is meant to solve and B: must not interact strongly with anything, including itself, to solve the problems it is meant to solve, it seems unlikely that it can be supporting any structures whatsoever, let alone usefully living or computing ones.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoI don't think that's quite right. I think that it can't interact with anything electromagnetically, and it can't strongly interact with even itself at larger distances. But it could support something similar to the strong force with itself, and could therefore have structure at smaller scales ("smaller" means perhaps even at the scale of a planet). Or have I missed something?
- landryraccoon 11y agoDark matter is believed to be very weakly self interacting. If it had any type of self interaction it is assumed that it would aggregate into large structures (like stars) because it would lose momentum due to collisions or "drag" interacting with other dark matter. We would expect to observe structures like dark matter stars/galaxies/planets, but no such structures are observed. Even if those large structures did not interact electromagnetically, the gravitational effects of those objects would be felt on "ordinary matter" like stars and galaxies that we could observe.
- kordless 11y ago> I'm not so sure we can reasonably imagine the signature of a civilization "subliming" Based on the number of people lost in their phones on BART, the streets and meetings, I'd say we're already well on our way to subliming ourselves.