9 ms·
Also, the original kickstarter [1] was for $50,000 with $72,000 raised. I'm not an expert on the economics of the video game industry, but I can't believe that
by michaelt 11y ago
Also, the original kickstarter [1] was for $50,000 with $72,000 raised.
I'm not an expert on the economics of the video game industry, but I can't believe that would pay a team of 6-10 people for very long.
[1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/45588301/woolfe-the-red-hood-diaries/description https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/45588301/woolfe-the-red...
- jeremiep 11y agoBarely one programmer for less than a year.
- dragontamer 11y agoIt was probably enough for a loan however. Which is probably why the company folded at this time, because they ran out of funding and couldn't make it. With that said, I've been following Patreon and the financial models at Patreon just make more sense than Kickstarter. Various game development groups have constantly slipped their schedule, and backers respond typically by keeping the donations steady. As long as the game developer releases a demo demonstrating progress, backers are more than eager to continue their $5/month or so funding. The main issue is the slow pace of early Patreon funding. A lot of games have to bootstrap with $500 / month or $1000/month for two or three months. Even "successful" Patreons only get $3000/month to $5000/month, and those are few and far between. (Patreon doesn't seem to have the reach of Kickstarter or Indiegogo quite yet. Perhaps if Patreon expanded and grew it'd be better?). The Patreon model is also better for "subscription" stuffs. Podcasts, youtube videos and the like are more popular there. I can't find too many games on Patreon by searching, but I've seen them advertized on various forums. In any case, even with $5000/month, it'd be hard to run a team of 6 on such meager money. I've been following a team of 3 and they're barely making it on that. But Patreon does strike me as more plausible than Kickstarter. ----------- On the other hand, Kickstarter is extremely good at measuring "hype". So perhaps the Kickstarter model is better if you're trying to prove to outside funding groups that your team is worth investing into.
- chx 11y agoPatreon seems awesome for one person teams: musicians, cartoonists etc. One of my favorites, Peter Hollens is above $7k/month now.
- dragontamer 11y agoI don't think Destin (Smarter Every Day) is a single-person team, but he's making $6.8k/video, with two videos per month. Patreon seems to work out for smaller-scale projects, like youtube videos or podcasts. Its a bit harder to map it to a video game, but I still think the Patreon model for video games is superior to Kickstarter. Everything is crap though, some real innovation should happen in this space. Unfortunately, I'm out of ideas...
- igorgue 11y agoThey're based on Antwerp, Belgium, That could make it work. Since the regular salary is $24k I'd expect it to be around $5k per person.
- raverbashing 11y ago> Since the regular salary is $24k Where did you take this number from? Try at least, the bare minimum, double that in Western Europe for anyone calling themselves a game developer
- jacalata 11y agoThat sounds like the number for the average salary in Belgium.
- rockdoe 11y agoOn the receiving end, yes. PSA: You have to pay taxes. And in Belgium, you have to pay A LOT of taxes. It's one of the most taxed countries in the world: http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/20121020_inc285_0.png http://www.ritholtz.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/2012...
- jacalata 11y agoHuh? Are you saying that 24k is the average after-tax salary? If not, I don't see how taxes are relevant.
- gambiting 11y agoLol. I work as a programmer in one of the largest studios in the UK and make $30k/year. Games industry is brutal with wages.
- raverbashing 11y agoUSD or GBP?
- numbsafari 11y agoDepends on what the backend motivations are. Clearly, the amount of work involved here was way too much. But if 72k can keep you alive on ramen and a futon so that you can make millions on the back-end ... Regardless, it's a gamble. But the up-front money isn't the only consideration. Especially if everyone has a real stake (which is not the case for startups in general).
- pmr_ 11y ago72k can keep you alive on sub-standard living conditions, but it will not keep a team of 6-7 talented programmers and artists alive for very long. Not even for way below market pay and working in a garage. And a single person just cannot turn out something close to a AAA title.
- dkersten 11y agoDon't forget that they get a good chunk less than 72k. You gotta factor in KS' cut and the cost of obtaining and shipping the physical rewards. I feel like a lot of people underestimate the work/cost involved in physical rewards. I remember reading a game devs blog post about the subject.
- tcdent 11y agoDefinitely not enough cash. Overwhelmed by rewards seems to be a common failure on KS. The list he rattles off in this case is quite extensive, and the postage cost is all that's preventing it from being sent. I wouldn't be surprised if they have 10k into rewards alone, especially when you account the time spent developing them.
- numbsafari 11y agoDefinitely not. I'm getting at the issue of employees versus founders. I'm responding to the commenters less than the OP. A lot of people are implying that the 72k would be spent on wages. If that was the expectation, then that's part of the failure. I have friends who've launched XBLA games on much, much less working full time out of a basement. During development, they could barely pay rent. Afterwards, they buy new houses. I feel like people don't take real risks any more, and seem to misunderstand what actual ownership of the outcome looks like. Sign of the times? And the issue of AAA ... well... Get a simple game or playable demo going and build off of that rather than shooting for the stars. Or did we lose site of what an MVP is, too? Sounds like the OP did.
- S_A_P 11y agoAgreed. That number should have been a red flag from the beginning.* *unless this was a legitimate case of being 1 month away from launch.
- aikah 11y agoIt was way too little money ... but I guess what happened is that they expected a third party investor to complete the development budget given the success of their KS campaign. Well it looks like it didn't happen. In my opinion , if one choose this strategy, one should make sure some investors are actually interested,even better, sign an agreement with potential "angels" before launching a campaign.
- differentView 11y agoSeems like if they had signed agreements from angel investors, their time would be better spent making the game than to raise $50k.
- dkersten 11y agoI won't back games unless they either ask for a few 100k, or are vastly over target already. The reason is that I'd rather back someone with a realistic, workable (but maybe a bit too high) budget than someone optimistic about a probably too low budget. Double so if they state that they want to hire someone. I see a lot of kickstarter project where a team of 5 is looking for 20K or somesuch. While some teams can and do pull it off, that just seems crazy low and too much risk (especially when you factor in KS' fee and cost of rewards). EDIT: Removed the as a rule from the first sentence (was I, as a rule, won't back...). After reading andallas' reply, I realised that there are some very rare occasions where I do back projects I otherwise wouldn't, but they have to have really proven themselves.
- andallas 11y agoKeep in mind that there are also experienced studios that don't get all their funding from Kickstarter. I don't know (and doubt) if this was the case with this Kickstarter project. $50,000 could have afforded them an artist for 6 months, or helped them to secure some essential software, or just supplemented the incomes of the existing team, while they continued doing 'side-jobs' to generally pay the bills. Now ideally, they would get all their funding from one source (so we know what they received) and it would be enough to pay for everything. But I think a lot of people who pledge on Kickstarter have a gross misunderstanding of how much money a game takes, considering each team-member may have a salary ranging from $50k - $100k is not unreasonable at all.
- lotharbot 11y agoI thought it was interesting to be heavily invested in one Kickstarter as it made it to the finish line with just a few hours to go, while watching a similar one fail a little while after. Descent:Underground [0] and Starfighter Inc. [1] both had well-seasoned teams of industry veterans, including founders who had written popular space games (X-Wing, Wing Commander). One of the big differences I identified between the two campaigns was that D:U asked for an amount of money that seemed like enough to run a small game studio for a year ($600,000) while SI asked for an amount of money that seemed like it wouldn't get them anywhere close to done ($250,000 for a bigger team). D:U was also really clear in their messaging -- if we don't raise the funds, that's a market signal that we shouldn't make this game. SI communicated several times that if they didn't reach their KS goal they'd just do it another way. What that indicated to me is that D:U had a realistic crowdfunding plan that could get them to release, while SI seemed not to know what they were trying to accomplish with kickstarter. To be sure, there were a lot of other factors at play. With D:U, Eric Peterson pulled a lot of support from Star Citizen backers and they released an excellent trailer in the last 48 hours of the kickstarter. SI dodged questions about what engine they were using and had a number of other customer interaction problems. But I think one of the big issues was that they didn't ask for a realistic amount of money, which made it seem like they either didn't know what they were doing or were relying on additional funding which would increase the risk for kickstarter backers. [0] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/descendentstudios/descent-underground/description https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/descendentstudios/desce... [1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/impellerstudios/starfighter-inc https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/impellerstudios/starfig...
- IkmoIkmo 11y agoThe game's prototype was funded and built in 2013, then by mid 2014 the entire game was already funded and close to completion, by September they finished the kickstarter and aimed to wrap it up by February. Consider that they're a game dev since 2002 and had other projects and income, too. So bridging September to February on $70k for a small team of about 5-6 people who are working on the project part-time, isn't crazy. I think they failed to earmark the funds for rewards (they did ship the game, the issue is they didn't ship the art books, wallpapers etc, and went bankrupt), and mostly just failed to build an awesome enough game. They probably expected strong sales as they'd been hyped quite a bit, greenlit in a few days, featured at the E3 etc. But when the sales didn't happen and the loans had to be paid back etc, they went bankrupt and couldn't ship the merchandise rewards.