3 ms·
> Because of the politics Precisely, but not because of the second-half of your sentence. From my experience the problem lies in the revolutionary governments
by zamalek 11y ago
> Because of the politics
Precisely, but not because of the second-half of your sentence. From my experience the problem lies in the revolutionary governments not being voted out: what has typically happened is the governments continue to fight the revolutionary war (which has long-since ended) instead of trying to fix the problems that the oppression of the past created. In some instances the government and governmental systems also become completely fixated on, in complete truth, getting revenge - this is especially true in Zimbabwe and South Africa.
One specific example (which is a very touchy subject). South Africa currently lacks electrical power production capacity: homes and businesses can expect up to 8 hours of blackout per week. The electricity utility company made the government aware of this issue circa 2005, at which point the power grid was nearing capacity. This was (and continues to be) because little-to-no capacity upgrades occurred. Instead the government was focusing on ending apartheid: even though that era had ended. It is this kind of focus on the past (instead of the future) that is driving portions of the continent into the ground.
I don't think it's entirely the fault of all of these governments either: they were born out of strife and it's natural that they would continue to cause strife. What should have happened is them being voted out: the problem there is that (due to apartheid and colonization) people were not educated enough to realize the change that needed to occur. The particularly villainous governments, being power hungry and revengeful, would also bribe the impoverished (with food) to vote for them or outright use violence and fear (Zimbabwe). Education remains a sorry story and it's thought that this is purposeful. In South Africa there is some hope, as I do believe Madiba did as much as he could to educate the people. This completely ceased when he stepped down, though. South Africa had so much potential during his reign.
A smaller, but still significant issue, is that Africa is being looted by the rest of the world. E.g. Anglo-Platinum: South Africa exports raw platinum only to re-import the refined product at a higher price. Building our own refineries is a blue sky dream because Anglo-Platinum would pull out, and, we don't have enough electricity to run such facilities. Many of our raw materials share this fate.
Keep in mind that this is not a universal result in Africa. I hear that Botswana is doing pretty well. This an opinion after living here for 28 years - so I may be somewhat jaded (although you may still find an insider opinion interesting), the truth may be out of grasp for many of us. I can agree with much of what is said in the article. Most assuredly Africa is a very complex place, which would lead to drastically varying opinions about it (especially for those living in it).
- panglott 11y agoTo what extent are African countries coherent nation-states in the sense of Europe, America, or Japan? Many are organized along former colonial borders and are very diverse, multiethnic, and multinational. This means that political legitimacy, state capacity, transparency against corruption, social trust, social coordination, and collective action problems generally can be more difficult. I'm often skeptical of the common insistence that national borders never change (as in Somalia/Puntland), but see the problems in South Sudan, which appears to be collapsing into open ethnic conflict. There's of course not going to be one reason why the continent as a whole is undeveloped. Take the argument for example: "Scholars such as the economist William Easterly, for example, have argued that even now, the effects of the African slave trade can be measured on the continent, with areas that experienced intensive slaving still showing greater instability, a lack of social trust, and lower growth." The slave trade undoubtedly had a long-term negative impact on Africa. But the slave trade itself was an indigenous African institution where intergroup conflict led to the capture of people from competing groups. The Atlantic slave trade just created an export market for people who might have just simply been killed otherwise, and the influx of guns and trade goods for slaves led to the formation of states that were more dependent on warfare and the slave economy, such as Dahomey. That's a combination of internal and external factors yielding a destructive system. But it also means the Congo was a place of intense intergroup conflict long before the Second Congo War. It's a pretty great article for pointing out how internal factors (conflict, lack of political legitimacy, &c.) allow external actors like profiteering corporations to support bad governance in Africa. But it's important to remember that a lot of progress and economic development HAS been made in Africa, especially in recent years. There has been lots of economic growth worldwide at the low end of the economic scale. And if extractive multinationals propping up corrupt local collaborators amounts to cover colonialism, well at least that's not overt colonialism.