7 ms·
Horrible. This is what's so scary about the free market and our current chemical regulations of innocent until proved guilty. People cover up, even the biggest
by azinman2 11y ago
Horrible. This is what's so scary about the free market and our current chemical regulations of innocent until proved guilty.
People cover up, even the biggest most "professional" here (DuPont), and the public gets decades of abuse.
Why is it that medication requires FDA approval with lots of animal/human tests before you can sell it, but chemicals do not? Here the tests internally done showed prove of issue year after year, and would have been a big red flag.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- makomk 11y agoApparently it was also sold: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid#Applications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfluorooctanoic_acid#Applica...
- icebraining 11y agoSorry, I deleted my post when I re-read the story. Still, it's not clear that the levels in the products were enough to have harmful effects, the problem was really the lack of care handling it in the plant, and the unsafe disposal.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- VMG 11y ago> This is what's so scary about the free market and our current chemical regulations of innocent until proved guilty. I get your point, but the situation is not much better in non-free markets as well. Regulators have a price for which they can be captured.
- juliangregorian 11y agoYou are correct, but "regulatory capture" refers to a different form of corruption than what you are talking about.
- Schwoisser 11y agoIt is worse. Look at the Soviet Union or China.
- azinman2 11y agoThe solution IMHO to have a climate of non-corruption (US) generally combined with enough pay already for regulators to not be easily swayed, and hopefully hire people who have different motivators than money in life, and actually jail for real people who violate this (too many abuses, particularly on Wall Street, go by without the true punishment it deserves). Despite existing corruption, I do believe the FDA is less corrupt than it is corrupt, and for the most part they do have the public good as their primary interest. My free market comment was more about this theory of self-regulation and trust. Clearly that gets violated time and time again, and here is yet another case to the point of knowingly harming their own employees for decades! The bigger issue is this non-regulatory environment for so many chemicals. Innocent until proven guilty, especially for thousands of drugs already popular when regulations were enacted (in the 60s?), is just irresponsible. The list of drugs in the blood of the entire pollution just keeps growing... How long before we realize the permanent harm potential?
- ekianjo 11y agoChemistry is far from being a free market. There are tons of regulations before you can produce anything in developed countries. The issue is rather that fines are too small and regulators can be easily bribed. You need an independent justice system more than anything else.
- 13years 11y agoFree markets when supported by strong property rights can have strong protections to prevent harm or pollution. Non free markets, although regulated, don't necessarily perform better and can even perform worse in this regard. The FDA is a great example of an agency which often can be seen to work harder to protect the industry than the individual. For example, look up the story of Vioxx. A drug which killed 50k people, passed all FDA processes and when the manufacturer was caught hiding data showing this would happen the product was not even removed from the market as that would have opened the door for lawsuits against the manufacturer.
- rayiner 11y agoProving causation in toxic torts make it pretty much impossible to hold companies accountable. Moreover, both judges and juries strongly side with companies, who create jobs. At best these cases settle for 5-10% of the damage caused, which make them a small tax on this destructive conduct.
- makomk 11y agoI think this article demonstrates why that doesn't actually work in practice. DuPont contaminated several counties with a toxic chemical over the course of a decade, affecting many people's property, yet because the owners didn't even know to test for it and weren't in a position to prove that it was dangerous, let alone prove that it had harmed them specifically, DuPont got away with this.
- 13years 11y agoPossibly, but it would seem to nonetheless also demonstrate why regulation also doesn't work in practice. From the article. "...THE FEDERAL TOXIC SUBSTANCES Control Act requires companies that work with chemicals to report to the Environmental Protection Agency any evidence they find that shows or even suggests that they are harmful..." What many people don't realize, is that EPA and FDA rely on the trust of the private industry to submit accurate test data. This was the same issue with Vioxx. People don't know to test also because they assume these agencies are protecting them. If property rights had more of a role, then there would be a greater call for testing and likely there would be more testing services available due to demand. From article. "... If these polluters were ever forced to clean up the chemical, which has been detected by the EPA 716 times across water systems in 29 states, and in some areas may be present at dangerous levels, the costs could be astronomical..." I doubt this will happen, since the regulatory agencies attempt to prevent harm to the industry. A proponent of property rights would have no issue with the companies paying for every bit of damages and cleanup no matter how much damage is done to the business even if it must be shutdown. Another example of EPA being aware of a problem and siding with industry against the individual http://www.ewg.org/research/free-pass-oil-and-gas/oil-and-gas-industry-exemptions http://www.ewg.org/research/free-pass-oil-and-gas/oil-and-ga... An example case in Canada where property rights did work http://environment.probeinternational.org/1993/07/17/how-they-killed-our-rights-clean-water/ http://environment.probeinternational.org/1993/07/17/how-the... This is a good reference on the history of environmental policy. In an interesting section here, the book states how property rights in the US were purposely weakened to allow for pollution. https://books.google.com/books?id=ZqRjI6JcgrMC&lpg=PA127&pg=PA126&hl=en#v=onepage&q&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=ZqRjI6JcgrMC&lpg=PA127&pg=... What I would like to see is a return to stronger enforcement of property rights by default and supplemented as necessary by agency regulation.