4 ms·

Which notebook to get: MacBook, MacBook Air, MacBook Pro?

11 points by getp 19y ago

inovica 19y ago
Well, I've just ordered a MacBook Air. My wife has a MacBook Pro which I love and I have held on using an old PowerBook 12". I don't like the MacBook (sorry to anyone who has one) as I find it too heavy and in a tactile way I just don't like it. The MacBook Air looks so cool and will be the light laptop that I've been waiting for. So what if it does have a few things - it has everything I need
- watmough 19y ago
  I waited for the MacBook Air, but having seen it, I have now replaced my stolen PB 12" with a base white MacBook. It kicks! My wife has one of the first ones sold by the Woodlands Apple Store, and it had every problem, but hopefully mine has all the bugs ironed out. The performance with the base 1Gig is great, and the keyboard and trackpad are excellent. My only complaint is reflections on the shiny screen, but you can't have everything.
comatose_kid 19y ago
I've bought a 15" macbook pro (2.16GHz model) and a more recent 17" macbook pro (thanks, work!). I prefer the 17" - it's not that much bigger than the 15, and offers significantly more res even without the 1920x1200 option. I don't think the macbook air would make a great dev machine.
- jgrahamc 19y ago
  Clearly the MBA is not a good development machine, you want as much screen as possible for that. I have a MBP 17" with the HD screen as my primary machine. I am very happy with it (and I've been through a lot of laptops starting way back with DOS based laptops, through all the Windows variants and with a Linux detour). MBP + VMWare is a perfect combination for me. Dual cores are really nice (have recently been doing some stuff on forgery detection in images, which I'll open source soon, and I can tie up an entire core doing image processing and not notice the difference).
kirubakaran 19y ago
What are doing to use it for? Dev / Scoring Chicks (like thats gonna happen) / Browsing... ?
icky 19y ago
I like the one that comes with Linux... ;-)
jmzachary 19y ago
Can I ask a more general question? Which type of notebooks are used around this readership? It's my impression that most of you use MBPs, but what about other Wintel notebooks, maybe running Linux? What computer do you use for 16 hours a day?
electric 19y ago
None of the above -- get yourself an asus eeepc instead.

11 points by getp 19y ago

Well, I've just ordered a MacBook Air. My wife has a MacBook Pro which I love and I have held on using an old PowerBook 12". I don't like the MacBook (sorry to anyone who has one) as I find it too heavy and in a tactile way I just don't like it. The MacBook Air looks so cool and will be the light laptop that I've been waiting for. So what if it does have a few things - it has everything I need

watmough 19y ago
I waited for the MacBook Air, but having seen it, I have now replaced my stolen PB 12" with a base white MacBook. It kicks! My wife has one of the first ones sold by the Woodlands Apple Store, and it had every problem, but hopefully mine has all the bugs ironed out. The performance with the base 1Gig is great, and the keyboard and trackpad are excellent. My only complaint is reflections on the shiny screen, but you can't have everything.

comatose_kid 19y ago

I've bought a 15" macbook pro (2.16GHz model) and a more recent 17" macbook pro (thanks, work!). I prefer the 17" - it's not that much bigger than the 15, and offers significantly more res even without the 1920x1200 option. I don't think the macbook air would make a great dev machine.

jgrahamc 19y ago
Clearly the MBA is not a good development machine, you want as much screen as possible for that. I have a MBP 17" with the HD screen as my primary machine. I am very happy with it (and I've been through a lot of laptops starting way back with DOS based laptops, through all the Windows variants and with a Linux detour). MBP + VMWare is a perfect combination for me. Dual cores are really nice (have recently been doing some stuff on forgery detection in images, which I'll open source soon, and I can tie up an entire core doing image processing and not notice the difference).

kirubakaran 19y ago

What are doing to use it for? Dev / Scoring Chicks (like thats gonna happen) / Browsing... ?

icky 19y ago

I like the one that comes with Linux... ;-)

jmzachary 19y ago

Can I ask a more general question? Which type of notebooks are used around this readership? It's my impression that most of you use MBPs, but what about other Wintel notebooks, maybe running Linux? What computer do you use for 16 hours a day?

electric 19y ago

None of the above -- get yourself an asus eeepc instead.