5 ms·
This looks like a good move to me. The text of the CC only has one potential problem area that I see: This code of conduct applies both within project sp
by tzs 11y ago
This looks like a good move to me. The text of the CC only has one potential problem area that I see:
This code of conduct applies both within project
spaces and in public spaces when an individual is
representing the project or its community.
The potential problem here is what does it mean to be "representing the project or its community"?
For example, suppose on my personal website I include a link to my resume, and on that resume I list my work on the project. Suppose also on my personal website I have have a blog, and on that blog I post an article containing sexualized language or imagery.
Am I in violation of the CC?
The use of sexualized language or imagery is one of the specific examples given in the CC of a violation.
I would say that, based on current common usage of English, stating on a site unrelated to the project, as part of biographical information (such as a resume) that I contribute to the project would NOT be "representing the project or its community", and so would be outside the scope of the CC.
- omginternets 11y ago>The text of the CC only has one potential problem area that I see Have we been reading the same thing? What about the part where they consider "other unethical or unprofessional conduct" to be violations of the CC? This whole thing is set up to be arbitrary and highly political in its application. I invite everyone to see the broad and hand-wavy language for themselves: http://contributor-covenant.org/version/1/2/0/code_of_conduct.md http://contributor-covenant.org/version/1/2/0/code_of_conduc... It's only 18 lines long, if you can believe it.
- VLM 11y agoThe meta problem is trying to discuss specific examples of rules lawyering when the purpose of one CC is to eliminate detailed rules lawyering isn't going to philosophically work well. None the less, for a corporate interpretation of the exact same topic but with respect to email: http://www.emaildisclaimers.com/Sample_disclaimers.htm#Liability http://www.emaildisclaimers.com/Sample_disclaimers.htm#Liabi... Generally speaking identifying yourself as a legal representative of a project or community has all kinds of interesting legal problems; you don't want the project sued because some idle conversation between some contributor and a service provider was seen by the provider as a verbal contract between them and the project for their services. Another example would be copyright, if the project owns the copyright to your self made pr0n example (because you posted it on the project wiki) then you're probably in huge trouble, but if everyone legally agrees you own the copyright and not the project, well, its kind of hard to argue you represent someone you're clearly not legally working for.
- faztym 11y agoThat clause was added after a devout Catholic who contributes to Opal expressed his thoughts on transgender people while talking about a piece of legislation in his country, Italy on his Twitter account. The person who wrote the Contributor Covenant went on to GitHub and demanded he be removed by the project. After much discussion, Opal's founder said they would adopt a code of conduct, specifically the Contributor Covenant. Once people in favor of the Contributor Covenant realized it would do nothing to prevent what they perceived as harassment, they added that clause. They tried to issue a PR to update Opal's Contributor Covenant version. Said founder seemed hesitant of the revised COC, but looks like he added the change but only with it explicitly saying where the code of conduct does and does not apply. See below. Some links: https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 https://github.com/opal/opal/issues/941 https://twitter.com/elia/status/611319469982527488 https://twitter.com/elia/status/611319469982527488 https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/961 https://github.com/opal/opal/pull/961 Opal's code of conduct says: "This code of conduct applies both within project spaces and in public spaces where an individual explicitly associates their presence with the project; non-project related material on accounts explicitly marked as personal should not be considered to be so associated."
- mordocai 11y agoI don't particularly like the way that whole thing was handled (and Coraline said she didn't feel she handled it optimally, even if she didn't apologize) but I think the concepts are still sound. Having someone post things in a public place where they identify as a member of a group can reflect badly on the group. It is in the group's best interest to enforce that people who identify with a group on a certain medium do not say/do things that would not be allowed on official group channels. This specific instance seems to have been intended to be interpreted differently than it was and did not need to be brought into the spotlight.
- exstudent2 11y ago> Having someone post things in a public place where they identify as a member of a group can reflect badly on the group. It is in the group's best interest to enforce that people who identify with a group on a certain medium do not say/do things that would not be allowed on official group channels. No one within the group had a problem though. Coraline Ada came from outside the group and caused the disturbance. > This specific instance seems to have been intended to be interpreted differently than it was and did not need to be brought into the spotlight. It's good that this instance is being brought into the spotlight because it shows the dangers of introducing identity politics into open source.