5 ms·
Very funny considering the uneasiness people have towards "putting Linux on a computer". For the Raspberry Pi, the reality is completely reversed as NOOBS is th
by teekert 11y ago
Very funny considering the uneasiness people have towards "putting Linux on a computer". For the Raspberry Pi, the reality is completely reversed as NOOBS is the absolute easiest, most convenient way to put any OS on any computer ever.
I really don't understand people who want this, with closed source software the learning stops at some point, you can't learn everything about your Windows-Pi even though it was created for learning! Even the example code (read I2C temp sensor, display using webserver) they give on the home page starts with: "// Copyright (c) Microsoft. All rights reserved.". Why would you want this? Can there really be people that are willing and able to build their own IOT but do not want to learn about Linux?
- nbadg 11y ago> Can there really be people that are willing and able to build their own IOT but do not want to learn about Linux? Absolutely, and especially in corporate environments. I'm not saying Windows 10 IoT is any better (I think it's very unlikely to be, but I also haven't evaluated it), but I can say for certain that I wish I had a single, identical python library for any IoT platform that handled interfaces as simply as: with pin_1 as p1: p1.output(1) time.sleep(2) p1.output(0) Now, there are some libraries that approach that level of simplicity once you have your system configuration set up, but that doesn't lend itself to agile development. I want something that works like that out-of-box -- flash it, load code, press go button -- which simply doesn't exist. And, after spending a lot of time writing my own hardware IO library using direct memory access in Python, I don't think there's an OS out there that's capable of doing it (yet). I've spent just way too much time accommodating unfortunate abstractions taken at the linux kernel level (that I understand for historical reasons, but disagree with for future ones). An operating system for IoT done right is, in my opinion, a very lightweight exokernel with some really smart abstractions that just gets out of your way. Then you need a clever (and native) secure networking system, and you're in very good shape.
- nitrogen 11y agoHow does Arduino (which I've never used) compare to your desired Python library?
- netik 11y agoI'm not sure if you've dealt with Arduino in Processing, but it is exactly as you describe. void loop() { digitalWrite(ledPin, HIGH); // sets the LED on delay(1000); // waits for a second digitalWrite(ledPin, LOW); // sets the LED off delay(1000); // waits for a second }
- nbadg 11y agoArduino is awesomely easy in this regard, but lacks a proper operating system, and the individual pins have fewer modes than systems on a chip. That is, in a way, exactly my point: the operating systems we have are so bad at portable systems that going without one can actually make development easier. That's a big problem.
- netik 11y agoI think this is a 'right tool for the job' problem. Frequently you don't need an operating system to do basic tasks. I don't see this as a problem at all for simple things to a point. Even something that seems as complex as as reading a sensor and writing data out to a CF card doesn't require an OS if the basic library support is there.
- tracker1 11y agoIf you use BabelJS (ES6) you can write async methods that are very close to that with Node + johnny-five. https://github.com/rwaldron/johnny-five https://github.com/rwaldron/johnny-five
- teekert 11y agoLike this? from time import sleep import RPi.GPIO as GPIO GPIO.setmode(GPIO.BCM) GPIO.setup(2, GPIO.OUT) while 1: GPIO.output(2, False) sleep(2) GPIO.output(2, True) Perhaps I'm not understanding what you want exactly, you seem to know what you're doing.
- nbadg 11y agoThe problem is in pinmuxing. If you want to change the pins from their default modes, you're in for a world of pain. Systems on a chips (SoCs, basically run everything portable these days) are optimized to the point where different die pins can have different modes (GPIO, LCD framing, USB framing, might all be available, one at a time, on the same pin). Switching between them requires mucking about in the kernel and reconfiguring hardware and is, at least in my experience, incredibly painful. Also, the sysfs mappings that the easy bindings tend to be written from are very, very slow (like ~3+ orders of magnitude slower than they should be: http://hackaday.com/2013/12/07/speeding-up-beaglebone-black-gpio-a-thousand-times/ http://hackaday.com/2013/12/07/speeding-up-beaglebone-black-...).
- Nexxxeh 11y ago>Why would you want this? Can there really be people that are willing and able to build their own IOT but do not want to learn about Linux? Knowing about Linux doesn't mean assuming it's the best tool for the job at hand. I've used Linux, I've installed Linux, I've fixed a couple of broken Linux installs etc. I've compiled software on Linux. I've imaged an SD card for a Pi from Windows pre-Noobs. I've installed Rasbian using NOOBS. I've also played with Arduinos, although mainly using other peoples' libraries for time and network comms etc. I have not, however, written any serious software for Linux and I am not a Linux developer. I mostly use VS on Windows to develop software that will end up on Windows computers to be used by Windows users. I have the required physical equipment, software and skillset to make a solution that meets the end requirements using 10 Core on a Pi 2. I don't have that for Rasbian. I've no doubt Lady Ada has a tutorial somewhere to teach me enough to get it working, but why would I invest my time in that? I'd be better off using the skills I already have to accomplish this task. Then learning something completely different that will allow me to accomplish an end result I can't presently achieve.
- socceroos 11y agoOr, you know, compile to mono and thus keep 100% control over your lower stack.
- tracker1 11y agoHowever, with the example... you can just use node under linux on the rPI, and get a decent experience. I have no idea what binary module support for node (bignum, sqlite, and others come to mind) under Win10Core that might be common for something like this are... In general if you don't have build environment support for node, there is always an edge/corner case binary module you need. It's better in windows, but I'm not sure if Win10Core has a compiler on the device target. (And Python 2.7 for that matter)
- not_with_retard 11y agoIt's obvious you have not in fact used Linux, as everything you've tried to use as an excuse is 100% incorrect.
- slowmovintarget 11y agoI read the headline, considered it for a few moments, and the only response I could come up with was "No." Why would I put an OS on a computationally constrained device that is essentially guaranteed to spend a portion of the CPU time doing things I likely don't want done, for someone else (Microsoft in this case)?
- throwawaykf05 11y agoI've spent a decade and a half developing software for and deploying software to Linux, but never had to look at the code. Funnily enough, that's the same number of times I've had to look at the code for Windows and OSX, which I've been using for a comparable amount of time.
- teekert 11y agoI'm not talking about "developing for" I'm talking about "learning about." I have learned a lot about hardware using Gentoo, compiling my own kernel. If I wanted to I could look at the source code. I also never did, like you, I'm just saying there may be youngsters out there who would.
- yareally 11y agoHaving worked in both Linux and Windows shops, yes, there are people that would readily use Windows on a π, because that's what they know best. Could they use Linux? Yeah, probably, they're smart people. However, that's a bunch of extra steps when you really just want to get things working and hack around on some code. At some point they might get curious and try Linux on it as well, but I'm all for whatever makes it easier for someone to get into trying something new without a lot of burden. For some people that means using Windows so they can use the platform and tooling they're most familiar with (Visual Studio and .net). Yes, there's mono and such, but even that still brings its own complexity when you actually consider what else it takes to get set up and going for someone that's never used Linux before (or outside of some courses in college). It's like wanting to build furniture, but then told you should plant a tree, wait for that tree to grow, chop it down, cut it up for wood, then you can start building some furniture. Most people would give up long before actually making any furniture in that case.
- hvidgaard 11y agoI also suspect, without having tried Win10 IoT, that the interface is more polished, and building apps are simpler. You don't have the same freedom, but as long as the developers can do what they like, it's more than enough.
- jsingleton 11y agoYou're correct about Mono being complex. It was easier to install than IoT core though. Including installing the OS first. Having a package manager like apt is a revelation coming from a Windows and Mac world. I previously tried Mono on the Pi and it had lots of bugs related to the processor architecture. Problems with the hard float support stopped things like Datetime from working properly. This was a while ago so I imagine it's been fixed in a recent build. It shouldn't be a problem on the newer architecture of the Pi 2 either. I think it's better to bite the bullet and just learn Linux and Python. You can then add those skills to your CV along with Windows and C#.
- jsingleton 11y agoI tried the technical preview of IoT core and was underwhelmed. The mouse didn't even work! It jumped around erratically making it unusable. My experience with Linux on the Pi is that it just works out of the box. Simple things that you need to install a driver for on Windows are plug and play on Linux [0]. I installed the desktop Windows 10 preview just to flash the SD card. Although I read in the Mag Pi [1] that there is a Python script [2] to convert the image to a normal format. I'm a big fan of C# and I'm a professional .NET developer. It's my go to stack. Yet, I believe that the best way to use a Raspberry Pi is with Python on Linux. [0] https://unop.uk/dev/raspberry-pi-electricity-monitor https://unop.uk/dev/raspberry-pi-electricity-monitor [1] https://www.raspberrypi.org/magpi/issues/34/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/magpi/issues/34/ [2] https://github.com/t0x0/random https://github.com/t0x0/random
- UK-AL 11y agoIt's not meant to be a desktop. It meant to be be an embedded system with no mouse or keyboard and maybe a touchscreen.
- jsingleton 11y agoI completely get that but when the app you pushed to it requires interaction with a button then a mouse is more than just a nice to have.
- not_with_retard 11y agoIt ships with mouse drivers, they don't work.
- teekert 11y agoSomeone badly just needs to make a bit for bit image. Or is that illegal? In anycase, as long as I keep it offline I'd at least be willing to try it out, without a win 10 machine it's my only option.
- jsingleton 11y agoI've written up the process here: https://unop.uk/dev/windows-10-iot-core-public-release-for-raspberry-pi-2-install-and-first-impressions/ https://unop.uk/dev/windows-10-iot-core-public-release-for-r... I'd host the file but I imagine it will go out of date pretty quickly as MS change the original.