5 ms·
Supporting a proprietary platform on Raspberry Pi kind of defeats the point of the openness on which Raspberry Pi was built, no?
by mtgx 11y ago
Supporting a proprietary platform on Raspberry Pi kind of defeats the point of the openness on which Raspberry Pi was built, no?
- elsjaako 11y agoI don't see how you can practically have an open platform and then close it off to proprietary things.
- jackweirdy 11y agoThe commenter isn't saying it should be blocked, they're saying it's against the spirit of openness.
- elsjaako 11y agoThey were talking about "Supporting a proprietary platform", and I assumed they meant the hardware supporting Windows. If the hardware supporting Windows is somehow bad, that implies removing that support would be better. Maybe I'm wrong and they mean a person or organization, in which case I'm not sure who they mean. Windows does not appear on the official Raspberry Pi website front page or blog.
- joshuapants 11y agoThe Raspberry Pi may be openwashed, but it's not really that open. edit: oh no, I've run afoul of the Broadcom shills. Oh well.
- Jedd 11y agoTrue assessment or not, it's not a compelling reason in itself to encourage less free use(r)s of it.
- joshuapants 11y agoBeg pardon? The parent post was whining that running Windows wasn't in the open spirit of the project. The project was never open in a meaningful way, so it doesn't seem like a problem at all to do so. I'm not encouraging any particular software package, simply correcting a misconception.
- farresito 11y agoUnfortunately, there are a few parts of RPi that are closed, like the GPU, if I recall correctly, but I do agree with you that it sort of goes against the philosophy of tinkering that openness brings.
- tankenmate 11y agoThere is a reasonable Gallium / Mesa driver for the GPU on the way; for simple OpenGL / OpenCL workloads it works reasonably well. It is being actively worked on so it is still improving. https://wiki.freedesktop.org/dri/VC4/ https://wiki.freedesktop.org/dri/VC4/
- makomk 11y agoThe GPU is only partially closed. Unfortunately, the part of the GPU that's closed and requires a binary blob is the bit that boots the Pi, so you have to use closed-source code in order to do anything with the Pi at all - even stuff that doesn't use the GPU.