6 ms·
The simple way to fix that is - counterintuitively - to abolish all campaign finance restrictions. With vastly more money available, politicians would have to
by BurningFrog 11y ago
The simple way to fix that is - counterintuitively - to abolish all campaign finance restrictions.
With vastly more money available, politicians would have to spend far less, both in time and favors, to finance their campaigns.
- rhino369 11y agoI always wondered what would happen if instead of making donations a public disclosure, that we did the opposite. We make it illegal to tell people you donated to politicians. Totally secret. You can't quid pro quo if you don't know about the quid.
- stephengillie 11y agoIf you remove the incentive for a behavior, you'll usually end the behavior. AKA you'll see a precipitous decline in campaign donations.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoIf I ever ran for office, that's the approach I'd take: "Feel free to give me as much or as little funding as you like if you agree with my views, but the only way to change my views is to talk to me and convince me."
- twoodfin 11y agoShockingly (or not), I expect the vast majority of U.S. politicians would say that's exactly how they behave. How much you believe them is probably a good proxy for how important you think campaign finance issues are.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Shockingly (or not), I expect the vast majority of U.S. politicians would say that's exactly how they behave. Except I've never once seen such a claim actually made by any politician. So at the very least it seems likely to stand out. And as for how to believe them: "I intentionally have no access to the donor list, I have never seen the donor list, and if you tell me you've donated to my campaign I will have no particular reason to believe you, so don't bother".
- Bill_Dimm 11y ago> Except I've never once seen such a claim actually made by any politician. So at the very least it seems likely to stand out. Marco Rubio made a claim like that on Meet The Press two days ago. > I intentionally have no access to the donor list That would require doing away with the $50,000 per plate fundraising dinners.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Except I've never once seen such a claim actually made by any politician. I've seen it made by almost every politician I've seen questioned about the impact of particular donations, and most people defending campaign donations against proposals to regulate them more closely; and as a lifelong political junkie and Political Science major, those are things I've seen quite a lot of.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI see; I hadn't seen that, and that explains the pile of negative responses and downvotes to my original comment. Thanks for the explanation.
- toufka 11y agoWhat if someone just wants to pay for your dinner? Or figures out what sports game you're going to, and pays to rent out the entire row of seats next to you. Or pays to do the same for your staff - who advise you? That's the issue we face now, and precisely the issue Lessig is trying to combat; a subtle but very real form of purchasing power.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> What if someone just wants to pay for your dinner? As an opportunity to talk to me about an issue? There'd be far better channels for that. > Or figures out what sports game you're going to, and pays to rent out the entire row of seats next to you. Or pays to do the same for your staff - who advise you? Then I'd be very interested in how they managed to break my security and privacy, particularly to figure out what seat; that just seems more creepy than anything else. And it seems more like something you'd do to a candidate you don't want to see elected, considering the PR image it would project. (Also, do you mean "rent out and leave empty" or "rent out to fill with people who want to bug me/them"? Either one seems obnoxious; the first is wasteful and creates an awkward situation, and the second seems decidedly creepy.) If you want to talk about strange things people with money can do to campaigns, there's the whole "third-party campaign ad" thing to talk about. Whether you're doing it to support a candidate or to attack one.
- quonn 11y agoHow would you propose to implement this idea?
- aetherson 11y agoI don't know what his proposal is, but necessarily step one would have to be "a constitutional amendment voiding the First Amendment."
- rhino369 11y agoMaybe. But SCOTUS has been pretty huge leeway on government regulations on direct transfers to political campaigns.
- p_eter_p 11y agoHis proposed amendment is here: http://lessig.tumblr.com/post/14010963493/proposed-28th-amendment-beta-v9 http://lessig.tumblr.com/post/14010963493/proposed-28th-amen... And yeah, section 2: "The First Amendment shall not be construed to limit legislation enacted pursuant to this article, save to assure content and viewpoint neutrality. Neither shall the First Amendment be construed to limit the equivalent power of state or local legislation enacted to regulate elections of state or local officers. Nor shall the First Amendment be construed to vest in any non-natural person any unalienable constitutional rights."
- aetherson 11y agoOh good. So, to be clear, this proposed Amendment would legalize literally any burden on speech so long as the speech was not literally one person speaking alone using entirely their own money? Like, under this Amendment, Congress passed a law saying "specifically the Democratic National Committee does not get to engage in any speech of any kind -- it may send no correspondence, buy no advertising, write no editorials," that'd be okay because the DNC is a non-natural person and as such has no rights under the First Amendment. The extent to which people on the left have let the very words "corporate personhood," utterly divorced from any actual implications thereof, becomes a bugaboo that drives them to silly positions is really amazing.
- SilasX 11y agoIt doesn't seem like this approach depends on people not telling; the mere fact of it being unprovable does all the work. At that point, it doesn't matter if you tell a politician you voted for them, because you could be lying and they'd never know.
- Uehreka 11y agoHonestly curious here: Wouldn't that lead to a sort of "financial arms race"? Even if you have enough money to buy a hourly running TV ad in Ohio, what if your opponent (who spends less time "working" and more time fundraising) is able to buy an ad that runs every ten minutes? So you shirk your duties to get enough money for a ten-minutely TV ad, but now your opponent is shirking even more and getting huge, well placed Billboards... Not to mention that if the amount of money in politics increases, couldn't advertisers just increase the price of political ads to compensate?
- twoodfin 11y agoGreat! We radically underspend on elections relative to their importance. We're talking about a $3T government running a $17T economy. Yet we spend roughly as much in the average election year as Apple's revenue from a week of selling iPhones.
- trhway 11y agoand that makes the investment in politicians the most profitable investment available.
- MichaelGG 11y agoIs there any evidence of political advertising helping the country in any way? I've had limited exposure, but every one I've seen is either content free (smiling face, vague promise), or sounds manipulative. Why not completely ban political advertising, requiring information on the parties to be released via their own website plus a master list. As well as equal airtime on news channels if coverage is actually that important to have. That'd also provide a slight chance of breaking this terrible 2 party system the US is stuck in, which seems to prevent any possibility of actual change.
- nickff 11y agoYou are the one proposing a restriction on a fundamental right, the burden of proof of necessity is on you.
- s73v3r 11y agoThis is right up there with abolishing all food safety regulations in the hopes that companies will try to be safe out of the goodness of their hearts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rpedela 11y agoI believe that is how campaigns were financed originally more or less [1] and then it was reformed because it was causing problems. Let us not repeat history. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_reform_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_reform_in_the...
- jessaustin 11y agoDo you really think we're better off now than we were in the 1970s?
- rpedela 11y agoI dont know if we are or not, but that isnt the point. The point is that prior to the reforms, campaign finance was problematic. Since it is still a problem, I would say the reforms didnt fix the problem completely if at all. Therefore we need another, better reform rather than going backwards in my opinion.
- jessaustin 11y agoIf you don't know why reform didn't fix the problem, and you propose even more reform, that is very much to the point. We're deep in the hole already, and you're ordering more shovels.
- rpedela 11y agoLet us use a CS analogy. There is a critical bug A and solution B does not completely fix the problem. What do you do? 1. Throw your hands up and remove the imperfect solution. 2. Leave it alone because solution B partially fixes the problem. 3. Find solution C which completely solves the problem. I hope you would pick #3 like all great engineers would.
- jessaustin 11y agoAt the risk of engaging in activity that Neal Stephenson would consider "undignified", I'm going to criticize this analogy, and offer a different one. No government has ever had the command over its subjects that a programmer has over the components of a computer. Human societies are extremely nonlinear and resistant to arbitrary commands. Thus seemingly simple laws, like an alcohol prohibition, lead to wildly flawed results. Political advertising is even more closely coupled with other aspects of the system than is drinking alcohol. It's not a surprise that attempts to control political advertising of the naive, "we'll make a law against it" variety have failed to achieve their goals. They already tried using your analogy, and it didn't work. Instead, I'd suggest the process of A/B testing as a potentially insightful analogy. It's a bit of a dark art, but in general we can say that after injecting orange into the color scheme on the site, and finding that CTR drops 30% as a result, the next step is not to make the color scheme completely orange. Lessig needs to go back to the drawing board. He wants to fight corruption, and on that point I agree with him. He fixates on overturning Citizens United, which had precisely nothing to do with corruption, and on that point I think he suffers a failure of imagination.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIts been tried, and I don't think the evidence supports spending less in favors to secure the support of the wealthy interests that are needed to win campaigns with complete deregulation (perhaps less time, when its not uncommon for a politician to simply be a client of a particular wealthy sponsor.)
- BurningFrog 11y agoWhere can I see this evidence?