4 ms·
"“In my day” (I’m old now, my day was the late 80s early 90s), you visited the registrar’s office. A financial aid office. The bursars office. I felt like an ad
by cryoshon 11y ago
"“In my day” (I’m old now, my day was the late 80s early 90s), you visited the registrar’s office. A financial aid office. The bursars office. I felt like an adult, making decisions and finding things out for myself… But now there are counsellors for everything. Counsellors. As if the very act of registering for a class is traumatic event for which the student needs counselling. According to some universities, these counsellors provide “customer support”. That’s Ohio State’s term, not mine."
Wow, this feels really out of place. When I was in school from 2006-2011, there was definitively no feelings of being an adult permitted. The university encouraged parents to make any kind of financial aid / money related decisions, and encouraged leaving the students out of it. There were counselors for their use, if they were needed. Definitely agree with the gist of the author. On the other hand, people have been complaining about the weakness of the youth since Socrates, so I'm not sure that this article is signal rather than noise.
As far as exams being stressful, I'd say it's fine to give students a break and let them handle the stress however it helps. For most, it's their first exposure to "serious" evaluation of their work, and it is a bit daunting because their decisions are ineffable once made. Of course, the stress-mitigation strategies that the students learn during this time period are essential to their growth-- this isn't focused on enough, IMO. After being in the workforce for a while, exam time seems more like a vacation from stress rather than a stressful time to me. I wish that I had been able to pet a nice puppy during exam time.
I also wish that there were a "phase 2" of college to be taken after 5-10 years in the workforce. The education of having to provide for yourself imparts a lot of discipline and enthusiasm that I really could have used as a student. I could probably get eight bachelors' degrees in the time it took me to get two the first time around. College was a step in the maturation process for me-- a step that was a bit too small as a result of some of my mother institution's decisions.
In summary, colleges certainly coddle the students, and the students are eager to be coddled. But don't be too bitter: the students deserve their youth, too.
- enjo 11y agoI don't think the author is complaining about the weakness of youth, but rather the weakness of the adults running the asylum.
- herge 11y ago> The education of having to provide for yourself imparts a lot of discipline and enthusiasm I think you have it backwards. Higher learning should impart on you the discipline and enthusiasm you need for the workforce, and not the other way around.
- cryoshon 11y agoI agree that it should, but it doesn't.
- jazzyk 11y agoTo be young, IMO, is to question the status quo, be politically active (protest in the streets, if need be), come up with intellectually disruptive ideas, try new things, etc. The current generation is mostly politically apathetic, obsessing instead over silly things like being offended by law textbooks containing words like "rape" and "violate". Helicopter parenting is to blame, no question.
- Terr_ 11y ago> The university encouraged parents to make any kind of financial aid / money related decisions, and encouraged leaving the students out of it. I wonder if that has more to do with financial/economic changes (rather than cultural ones) particularly when you look at how tuition has changed in terms of amount and how loans are handled and by whom.