3 ms·
> Are there actually any numbers for this supposed infantilization? It seems to me that the number of people complaining about unis being not PC enough is relat
by mcphage 11y ago
> Are there actually any numbers for this supposed infantilization? It seems to me that the number of people complaining about unis being not PC enough is relatively equal to the number of people complaining about the first group.
Isn't this the same response we hear every time someone else speaks out about this? "This is just the work of a few bad eggs. If this was a widespread problem, why aren't we hearing about more of it?" Which, yeah, the first few times people have made this complaint, I agreed with. But it has started to ring hollow.
> Sometimes very small, very loud groups can be perceived by outsiders
I don't think the author here is an outsider—they're a professor at a university where this is happening.
- PaulHoule 11y agoThere is a pair of selfish memes here. "PC" is a meme and so is the attack on PC. For a bunch of reasons it is not feasible for people to talk about or expect any actions about the real problems they face (for instance, the cost of college, all of the ways the 'meritocracy' falls short that aren't connected with race and gender). (Oddly, for all the talk about race-class-gender, you never hear about class because a lot of history got forgotten in the 1960s. For instance, you hear about anti-semitism, but you don't hear that the Klu Klux Klan was an equal opportunity hate group at the peak of it's influence which hated irish people and italians, as well as blacks and jewish people.)
- selimthegrim 11y agoCertainly in my AP US History class (ca. 2003), we had the joys of reading primary source literature from the era in question (twenties) with such slogans as "Kick the Koons, Kikes, and Katholics", so no I wouldn't say it was forgotten
- a_bonobo 11y agoI can see your first point, but I still have to see yet any quantification (a shift in questionnaire answers towards more "PC" over the decades, for example), until then I remain unconvinced. Most cases in the author's article have to do with other universities - about the author's university, he complains about "counselors" (again, I think that's a financial incentive for the university - "customer support", happy customers study longer therefore pay more, special customers for groups who normally don't study -> more students from that group -> more money), and people in pajamas, which isn't really a problem that I can understand. Now that I've re-read it, it's a bit weird that a psychologist writes a sentence like this: > It seems that Harvard students, for whom the average grade is A- need more help. If you're expected to have an average of A- by your peers, teachers and professors of other universities then I'd expect the pressure to be enormous, of course you'll see more problems with mental health! >I must ensure that every every disability is accommodated. The poor man!
- matt-attack 11y ago>I must ensure that every every disability is accommodated. >> The poor man! Did you not read the next sentence? The point was that most of the "disabilities" are bunk: > Most disabilities that I am asked to accommodate seem to be unspecified and are remedied by providing the students with a separate, quiet location and an extra 30 minutes to take an exam.
- a_bonobo 11y agoHe doesn't prove that they are bunk - there are just many disabilities out there where a separate room is helpful. (edit: in fact, an extra room + bit of extra time is the only available accommodation for disabled that unis tend to give out, so of course that's the "remedy") For example, someone with a spine injury with a only partially functioning bladder may need to urinate a few times during a long exam. If he/she's not around students, he/she can do that using a bottle and doesn't need to waste any more time wheeling back and forth to the bathroom. (I have a friend in a wheelchair who used to do this during exams). Visually impaired may not be able to write or read on their own so they have someone read them the questions and dictate the answers, which disturbs other students if they'd be in the same room. AFAIK if you need a different room then the disability has to be documented to the university with a medical letter, but I can't find that requirement at the author's uni page so maybe that uni doesn't.
- chestervonwinch 11y ago> AFAIK if you need a different room then the disability has to be documented to the university with a medical letter, but I can't find that requirement at the author's uni page so maybe that uni doesn't. Just to add to this: I'm a TA and have been a lecturer a few times for courses at my uni. There is a whole registration process that the student and professor must go through. I'd estimate (in my limited experience) it's usually only 1 in 30-50 students who request extra accommodation. I suppose there are some that use it to take advantage. However, there are social implications of having special accommodations that naturally work to off set those who might take advantage these allowances.
- 11y ago
- RodericDay 11y agoHow has it started to ring hollow? The last time we had a similar piece, that Vox article with a prof complaining about "liberal academia scaring him", he wasn't countered with mere notions that he was inflating a non-issue, but actual counter-factuals regarding his exact claims (ie: that discussions of abortion were stifled by "liberals", for example). I don't think there's any topic that's more "Pro-Skub" vs "Anti-Skub" in the entire internet than "Outrage Culture" vs. "People outraged at Outrage Culture".