4 ms·
I don't understand how it's accurate to a micron - that grinding wheel wears after use. Wouldn't that throw off the accuracy? I was expecting some sort of lase
by ars 11y ago
I don't understand how it's accurate to a micron - that grinding wheel wears after use. Wouldn't that throw off the accuracy?
I was expecting some sort of laser calibration during cutting but he didn't say anything like that. (i.e. don't make the machine accurate to a micron, just measure accurate to a micron and adjust the cutting real time.)
- blackguardx 11y agoI don't think he was specifically talking about grinding applications per se, but the overall build accuracy of the machine. If you had a perfect grinder or cutter, most machines would have some twist or lack of rigidity or distortion of components that would lead to inaccuracies as the part is turned. Because of the way this machine is built, it is capable of achieving 1 micron accuracy. It most certainly takes extremely careful setups (and accounting for wear) to achieve this accuracy, though.
- th0ma5 11y agoI did seem to get the impression that he could start at a reference point. He also mentioned zeroing out the set up. It also seems very possible even without calibration that once the apparatus was in operation that subsequent operations would be relatively accurate to each other within a micron. But yes, overall it seemed to me that absolute precision was potentially a whole other can of worms.
- Animats 11y agoThe grinding wheel has to be "dressed" to make it flat. This is typically done with a diamond-faced tool.[1] [1] http://www.nortonindustrial.com/DressingTools-BladeTools.aspx http://www.nortonindustrial.com/DressingTools-BladeTools.asp...
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's why grinding wheels have such huge diameter (inner grinding is much harder because of that), clamps are typically non-distorting (magnetic) and the force involved is a very small fraction of what happens during normal turning/milling. In finish grinding after your setup the trick is to remove very little per pass so the workpiece does not warm up which would cause it to expand removing too much material. That's why you use coolant and not so much a cutting fluid (this also helps to flush out the residue from the stone and the material being ground). A single pass will remove a fraction of a micrometer (100 to 500 nm) and you count passes. Another thing to keep in mind is that a lathe with an accuracy of motion of 1u produces workpieces with a diameter accuracy of 2u. Doing this repeatably is really hard, and doing it in absolute terms is witchcraft of a higher order. Usually accuracy of a ground product is not only about the diameter or some other dimension of the workpiece but about flatness of the surface or roundness (runout).
- robin_reala 11y ago(I always find the overall breadth of technical knowledge on HN impressive; seems like there’s always someone who knows an engineering area inside out)
- jacquesm 11y agoI've been out of the industry for more than 20 years now, a lot has happened in that time though that world does not move as fast as the software world I definitely would not say I know it 'inside out' (and probably never did in the first place). Machinists dedicate their lives to the work, I merely passed through and learned just enough of the domain to be able to do my job. The customers were super interesting, from a lathe that worked gold for watch cases (where the repeat accuracy was probably less important than the degree to which the machine managed to recover the cuttings) to one that turned wheels for harbor cranes and everything in between.
- WalterBright 11y agoWitchcraft is right. I tried really hard in college in the machine shop to accurately make parts, and failed pretty badly. The machinist who ran the shop would sometimes take pity on me, eyeball my setup, touch the tool bit to the grinding wheel, turn a knob a hair, and turn out perfect parts. It was maddening! A 4 jaw lathe chuck was my enemy. No way in hell was I ever able to center a part in it.
- luckydude 11y agoI know your misery. I've got a Logan 820 lathe (quick change gear box, does 8-224 threads per inch; change one gear and you can do 4 threads per inch). The ways are worn so to hold a 10 thousands over 5 inches I have to twist the bed. I twist it with a level like this on the carriage: http://www.starrett.com/metrology/product-detail/Precision-Measuring-Tools/Precision-Hand-Tools/Machinsts-Levels/Levels/199Z http://www.starrett.com/metrology/product-detail/Precision-M... I didn't get that one, $863 is spendy. I got a Russian copy for $150. Anyhoo, you put that level on the carriage and then crank the carriage back and forth over the range you want straight, adjust the levelers on the legs. I can turn mild (cold rolled) steel and hold a 10,000 of an inch for almost 5 inches and then it goes to hell. And the head stock bearing is crap, the originals had some preload but the replacements do not so I have to use a live center in the tailstock to put some load on them or it doesn't work. Watching that video? I'm in awe.
- hwillis 11y agoTouching off on the work piece with a sufficiently rigid setup is accurate to a micron... but there are tricks to it once you get down to that kind of precision.
- gaze 11y agoGrinding wheels wear from left to right. You dress it to a certain diameter and then particles come off the left part before they come off the right. That way SOME fraction of the width is at the proper diameter. This is why you never ever grind full width. Of course, once you grind long enough that you wear the whole width, game over.