3 ms·
I have been involved in a number of informal discussions on this topic, things like the Kessler effect effectively denying access to space is a possibility even
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
I have been involved in a number of informal discussions on this topic, things like the Kessler effect effectively denying access to space is a possibility even without malicious action (all you need is an asteroid to fly close enough to bat some of the geosyncronous satellites into a crossing orbit with the rest of the LEO stuff.
A number of scenarios start with just that, something happens and suddenly the space around the earth is so full of junk flying every which way that a new sort of "debris" belt prevents launching new Geo satellites or even people into orbit.
At which point the country that can build a space "tank" a hardened satellite which is designed to deflect damage from collisions wins.
Alternatively the ways in which things can be de-orbited can be increased. The laser idea has some good press going for it, I am partial to conductive tether tugs, but it is probably not going to be people up there taking out the trash.
And of course if someone does this deliberately how much of the US' military inventory is suddenly worthless? Predator drones, cruise missiles, gps guided bombs, auto-pilot features, iridium sat phones, gps laser designators, lots and lots of stuff. Not the kind of change that leads to extended space use.
- grandalf 11y agoI've thought about this a lot after reading some material about satellites and thinking about the consequences. What do you think would be the best strategy for defending the current fleet? It seems like 3 "tanks" in highly elliptical orbits could provide some defense against space based attacks, but not really against ground-based lasers.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoWithin the orbital mechanics you can really only put two defenders on station with the satellite (one ahead and one behind in the orbit). Fortunately most of the stuff is in an equatorial orbit rather than a polar orbit so that is probably good enough for most things. One wonders if you could create "chunks" of expanded foam and push it ahead and behind. You want to add enough delta-v to move what ever is threatening you into a lower orbit (assuming from a lower orbit it will de-orbit faster). Tether tugs basically have a glob of adhesive that works in space on one end, spool out a long conductor and then energize it with a small solar panel, it provides a constant back emf against the earths magnetic field. That slows you down, you orbit lower, and then the atmosphere takes over. Of course vacuum adhesives are quite a challenge.
- mmanfrin 11y agoIt boggles my mind that there are so many things we've put in to space that there is a danger of them colliding in to one another on a plane that is larger than the entire earth.
- bane 11y agoit's not so much that there's a lot of stuff up there, but it's moving around at absolutely incredible velocities, so the territory an individual fragment can cover is continent sized.
- jfoutz 11y agoI imagine your tanks as a little speck in the center of a 100 meter foam doughnut. but i guess it really depends on what the debris is like. I'd guess most would be with a few hundred m/s, faster would rise and slower would fall, right? Not sure how much kinetic energy could be converted to breaking chemical bonds.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThe problem is with debris on different orbits than yours. If you're on an equatorial and there's a debris on an elliptical polar one and you happen to meet near its periapsis, that could easily amount to 10km/s of speed difference. And don't get me started on retrograde orbits.
- jfoutz 11y agoOh! right. yeah. T-boned. thanks for the clarification.
- trhway 11y agothe faster the object, the more energy it has. How about collecting that energy? Your delta-V is my joules so to speak. The space junk is (and probably will be) mostly metal, and there probably some ways to collect the energy, like magnetic traps, etc... (the idea inspired by my Prius brake regeneration :)
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoInteresting idea. However, I doubt it can work, because for it to work, you have to be close to the debris. (You're probably facing some kind of inverse-square-law here.) But you don't want to get very close to space debris that can close on you at those kinds of speeds (I believe the GP from me meant 10K km/sec, rather than 10 km/sec.) It's going to be really hard to guarantee a miss and still get close enough to collect energy...
- TeMPOraL 11y ago
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI wonder how the current push towards cubesats and nanosats changes the equation. People seem to seriously think that launching hundreds of satellites in one go, half of which will turn straight from payload to debris, is a good idea. Another thought - maybe the future is not in satellites, but in aircrafts, like Project Loon's balloons and solar-powered high-altitude drones. Both will be much cheaper to make and launch, could easily take over most of the Earth-related responsibilities of satellites (meteo, agriculture, communications, spying) and offer much more flexibility (you can't exactly tell the satellite to hover or circle over a location for a while, and then circle over another one).