3 ms·
This: We value that highly, and if he expresses a little impatience or frustration... Is only due to the fact that Feynman actually tries hard. And if he's f
by ddingus 11y ago
This: We value that highly, and if he expresses a little impatience or frustration...
Is only due to the fact that Feynman actually tries hard. And if he's frustrated, or impatient, it's because he is challenged to understand who he is talking to and that makes it hard for him to understand how long it may take to get there --and he really wants them to get there.
Doing anything else sucks, because it doesn't mean anything and Feynman wants it to mean something. Getting at the basic meaning of things is what he lived for.
People tend to take this all sorts of ways. I find watching and reading about Feynman so notable, because all the bravado and aggression is just fun down deep. He's playful and in the play comes really great insights.
He related some of this in one of his stories about the Manhattan Project. He was young, and not yet of superior standing among his physics peers. A famous and very highly regarded physicist engaged Feynman on something one day, and Feynman told him he thought the whole thing nuts! No fear, just raw sharing of mind to mind.
That guy would come back and request more dialog time with Feynman because Feynman didn't fear him and just shared his thoughts and feelings about whatever it was unabashedly.
That is what people are seeing in the interview, and it's rare. Very, very rare.
The interviewer should be quite pleased to see Feynman sharing as he would with any peer and not coddling, or glossing over things for what Feynman would consider shallow and unproductive reasons.
Strange as it may appear now, Feynman was showing respect and giving the interview an honest go, not making a show for people who would watch such things as happy curios. Instead, it's a record for those who want to know something about Feynman.
And say what you want, Feynman tried hard to demonstrate good intent in his life. Remember that on passages like this.
And the good intent here is to spark the interest of the person asking why. Rather than punt, or cheat, he's going to say why, "why?" is tough and that he can't satisfy out of respect for a fellow person he would not want to lead astray. This does require going somewhat astray, but the person will be left with some greater understanding as a consequence, and that is as good as it gets, without actually taking the time to really answer why, which is entirely too much time and outside the scope of the interview mutually agreed upon in advance.
That look in the chair, when he sits back and grins a little? It's a challenge. He's opened up a door, and he's inviting anyone watching to go right on in. Think about it some more. Thinking is good, and down that rabbit hole is where the really good stuff is. :) People can get a notch smarter just watching Feynman, and that's as he intended.
He's just precise and he cares about that. Nothing nefarious or mean in any of it.
- m_mueller 11y agoI think this hits it precisely. One thing I'd like to add: > if he expresses a little impatience or frustration... IMO what sets Feynman off at the beginning is the way the Interviewer asks his question by describing his feeling when interacting with magnets. I can almost hear him think - "oh god, now it isn't only the magnetism that I should explain, but even this guy's feelings - am I a neuroscientist?" Physicists are trained to be precise with language, so asking about feelings when just trying to know how magnets act may be understandable to the common (wo)man, but people like Feynman stop being a common man when talking about physics. As soon as the interviewer rephrased it to the how question, his mood turned and something in there got unlocked. To me this is beautiful to watch.
- ddingus 11y agoRight on. He may also be thinking, "ok, where can I go with this that makes sense?" And yes, the how did good things. Feynman could then paint the broad strokes needed to spark the deeper thoughts he hope people will have.