4 ms·
On one hand, this account sounds overly dramatized (and quite rude calling the officers "broom pushers"), and it's hard to feel sympathy for people who take the
by kalleboo 11y ago
On one hand, this account sounds overly dramatized (and quite rude calling the officers "broom pushers"), and it's hard to feel sympathy for people who take the privilege of international travel too lightly by not researching the relevant visa regulations (especially when it's a journalist of all people).
On the other hand, US immigration and customs officials really do seem heavy-handed, and seem to revel in treating every tourist who filled out a form incorrectly or misunderstood some rules as the next Bin Laden.
Now it's just a TV show so I don't know how "cleaned-up" it is, but if you watch "Australia Border Patrol" they seem to have a much better relationship with their visitors. Many episodes have people arrive flouting quarantine rules or misrepresenting themselves still get let in, possibly just with a fine, since they get a change to explain themselves calmly and correct their mistakes and the officers come across as trying to help people rather than trip them up.
- billforsternz 11y ago> and it's hard to feel sympathy for people who take the privilege of international travel too lightly by not researching the relevant visa regulations Really? I travel internationally quite often. I'd never dream of "researching the relevant visa regulations". For example, my wife and I have twice booked river cruises through Europe, entering half a dozen countries each time. We did book through a travel agent, and I just assumed we would be fine. And we were. In my experience going from one first world country to another tends to be very low friction. The USA is becoming an increasingly huge outlier. I haven't been there for a while but actually I probably would do some visa research before going these days. Although having said that if I'd obtained an online visa waiver I'd consider that to count as sufficient research.
- serge2k 11y agoThe US seems to enjoy having overly complex processes and stupid rules for things. I mean Canada has a ton of red tape too (the passport system is horrendous). I just seem to run into these things more in the US.
- 16bytes 11y agoI completely agree with you. As a US citizen, I've found it easier to get through customs in France than to get back into the US. I find that fact completely astounding.
- viraptor 11y ago> take the privilege of international travel too lightly That's a weird expression. You mean too lightly compared to one country's overreaction of 9/11? Everything is light compared to that. As for Australian border, I've seen people going in, just paying the fine for whatever was not right (like too much tobacco in the luggage) and getting in without much problem. I've also had the "pleasure" of being told that's the last time I'm allowed in as a tourist. All of those interactions were a lot simpler than every one of my arrivals to the US where people saying "you can go" were way worse worse than people saying "there's a problem" in other places I visited.
- owen_griffiths 11y ago"one country's overreaction of 9/11" There is not any evidence that 9/11 has anything to do with this - this sounds more like a regular limitation of work rights issue. Hacker news regularly has stories about the difficulty of navigating the US work rights regime.
- viraptor 11y agoDeportation and visa issues - sure. But I only started to see the stories about bad treatment and jail-like airport detention centres after the overreaction. Were there any known ones before?
- coldtea 11y ago>"who take the privilege of international travel" The "privilege" huh?