7 ms·
I've always been puzzled by the fact that so many people see Feynman coming across as a jerk or something like that in this clip. I think it's because ordinary
by wtallis 11y ago
I've always been puzzled by the fact that so many people see Feynman coming across as a jerk or something like that in this clip. I think it's because ordinary everyday English language doesn't have a good way to tell someone that their question is wrong—that it's assuming something it shouldn't, and the assumption is what should be questioned instead. It's curious that even when asking for new knowledge, people can be affronted by the implication that they don't know what they're talking about. Physics is hardly the only field where you learn that the everyday understanding is an oversimplification, and a beginner being misled by those oversimplifications has no reason to be embarrassed.
- technomancy 11y ago> I think it's because ordinary everyday English language doesn't have a good way to tell someone that their question is wrong English is always stealing from other languages anyway; it's high time we stole 無 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mu_%28negative%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mu_%28negative%29)
- chm 11y agoTo me Feynman was acting like a jerk at that moment. He was aware of who was interviewing him and should have acted accordingly. He knew what the purpose of the interview was, and who the audience would be. He could have simply stated that the question can be answered with varying degrees of sophistication, but an ultimate "why" is not to be found. The journalist was in no way pretending to have any physics knowledge nor was he insinuating anything. He asked a totally reasonable question and wanted Feynman to talk about magnets, not rant about how there's no ultimate answer to a "why" question. Feynman was being arrogant and patronizing when he shouldn't have been. Just search for "why" on this[1] page and see if he himselfs asks "why" questions. [1]:http://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_01.html http://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/I_01.html EDIT: Alright, this turned into a tiring argument about who's right or wrong, when in this context it's a non-issue. People react differently to his sermon, end of the question. Is Feynman right about "why" questions? I think so. Was it necessary to make the point as he did when he did? I don't think so. And please stop making assumptions about me. I'm all for discussion, but you need not assume anything, just as I reciprocate. You have no idea who I am, and nor I you, but we can still talk!
- wtallis 11y ago> He could have simply stated that the question can be answered with varying degrees of sophistication, but an ultimate "why" is not to be found. That seems to me like a pretty vacuous answer. An "ultimate why" is almost never possible, saying that he couldn't answer the question would have been inaccurate, and just saying that he could only answer the question in a way that the audience couldn't understand would have been a hell of a lot more patronizing. I think you may have missed Feynman's point about "why" questions. He wasn't merely pointing out that you can keep on asking "why", and he wasn't saying that there was something wrong with asking "why". He was pointing out that where you let it stop depends on the context. In the context of everyday non-physicist understanding, you really can't correctly answer "why do magnets repel?" with anything much deeper than "they just do", but if you're willing to bring in significantly more advanced concepts you can go several layers deeper and explain the math behind interaction of magnetic fields and how ferromagnetism arises and so on. But there's a pretty big gap between the layman explanation and the next most detailed explanation that isn't highly misleading.
- chm 11y agoHe was pointing out that where you let it stop depends on the context. And there you have said it. I haven't missed the point. Feynman did by not acting on the context of the interviewer's question. Of course he had to stop somewhere in his explanations. But he definitely could have talked about magnetic fields, and electrons, and spin, etc. instead of giving a sermon. Really, by that logic, he could simply have stopped the interview and sent the journalist to college for a physics degree.
- simoncion 11y agoIf you go to the linked YouTube video, you will see that this one conversation is one of a series of conversations in a larger production. wtallis pointed out elsewhere in this thread that this was a BBC production for a largely non-technical audience. You have missed the point because you were unaware of the larger context in which that one conversation sat. :)
- simoncion 11y agoAgreed. I'm even more puzzled that folks on HN would misunderstand Feynman's rhetorical style. I get the impression that most folks on HN work in a technical role. Most technical people find themselves performing some combination of either explaining complex concepts to folks with varying backgrounds or requirements gathering from folks with a variety of backgrounds. In both activities you will sometimes find yourself obligated to provide background information in order to either steer a conversation in order to make sense of someone's request, or to help someone understand your explanation.
- MaulingMonkey 11y ago> I think it's because ordinary everyday English language doesn't have a good way to tell someone that their question is wrong Many people have a tendency to get defensive when it's pointed out that they're wrong about something in general. They have difficulty separating an attack on, say, a logical falsehood, from an attack on their character or themselves. This is doubly true if the other party seems frustrated, which Feynman seems like he might have been - if only a little, and no matter how understandably - because even if you can convince yourself rationally of the difference, you're now dealing with emotions, and convincing yourself emotionally of the difference is a whole different - and I believe more difficult - challenge. Especially because they're not always separated. If someone criticizes everything you ever do, it's likely because they're critical of you. I can read "all your code sucks, it's terrible, you suck at writing code" and interpret it as a generalized self-deprecating comment about human fallibility in the context of programming, the tongue-in-cheek rationale about why we should all use static typing, unit tests, fuzzing, LISP, or whatever. However, I've had the advantage of decades of dealing with this stuff, of dealing with my own mistakes and the mistakes of others, and being frustrated by it, and enjoying the benefits of being corrected. Were such corrections a controlled substance, I'd be addicted or dead from overdose at this point. I've come to value them, and I can appreciate the truth of the in-joke. Yet if I repeat it to my mother - without carefully bracketing it in explanations - it'll just be extremely rude. Not because she can't or doesn't appreciate the knowledge, or the fundamental point, but because in her experience, "you suck" is a personal attack - it hasn't been twisted into some kind of fundamental greek tragedy of programming like it has in mine. But returning to Feynman - to me, and I believe to you - he comes across as someone willing to explain to us in great detail things in ways we'll understand. We value that highly, and if he expresses a little impatience or frustration, we look past that as a completely natural, a place we've all been, and don't take it personally. If anything, we might appreciate that he doesn't feel the need to coddle us. To others, that he can't even be bothered to hide his impatience or frustration with us, as social etiquette might demand, is rude - not something to be appreciated. He puts on a grand show of how even the interviewer's question is flawed, raising himself at the expense of the interviewer. There's a higher sensitivity to social cohesion - likely quite reasonably, as their day jobs value that social cohesion more. It's at odds with the more... militant style of pursuing the truth, of cutting straight to the point and making it clear without sugarcoating it in niceties. That he has a point only means we can begrudgingly appreciate it instead of just being offended.
- Turing_Machine 11y agoI wonder if the people who read it that way haven't spent a lot of time around people from the East Coast. It's an attitude that isn't necessarily arrogant or aggressive, at all, but may come across that way to people from regions with a less straightforward presentation style.
- simoncion 11y agoAgreed. Southeasterners as a class strongly dislike dealing with Northeasterners. In my experience, this directness and terseness is a pedagogical style that's prevalent amongst technical folks -engineers, programmers, scientists- from all over. When you're explaining something complex it is important to be precise. When everyone involved in the conversation has some degree of mutual respect for each other, one can safely dispense with much of the genuflection often demanded by others. Perhaps my experience is atypical.
- mercer 11y agoMy experience is similar. In certain circles, usually the technical realm, but also in my family when we discuss mostly social and religious issues, there is the ability to be blunt and to the point without hurting anyone's feelings. I often miss that freedom in many of my other interactions, where every discussion is bogged down by 'negotiation' and pleasantries, all to avoid direct disagreement based on concrete arguments. That said, I also think technical types especially have a tendency to forget that in many conversations there is a personal aspect where feelings can get hurt, and that in those cases being blunt can and does hurt feelings, and detracts from the objective of the conversation. Interestingly, this personal aspect can often be present in conversations where they don't appear to be at first, and even more interestingly I've found that 'we' technical types can be rather unaware of our own personal feelings in such conversations. I've often only realized that I was much more emotionally invested in the topic after the conversation, and at least part of my behavior was just rationalizing feelings. An example is the programming language, 'stack' or editor we use. I could swear that I can discuss this rationally, and yet I've had a number of discussions where, in hindsight, I was really just defending my personal preference, and I was really just annoyed that the other person could not 'see the light'. EDIT: 'The light' being Vim, of course. Anyone who says otherwise is objectively wrong.