3 ms·
No human composer will ever produce convincing imitations because the only test that will be accepted as "convincing" is the judgment of an expert. Experts are
by mrob 11y ago
No human composer will ever produce convincing imitations because the only test that will be accepted as "convincing" is the judgment of an expert. Experts are familiar with the complete works of those famous composers, so they will immediately know the imitation is an imitation. Their knowledge makes them incapable of unbiased judgment. A blind test is impossible. Even tricking the expert into thinking a new genuine work has been discovered won't help, because they will know that is much less likely than an imitation being written.
I've listened to a lot of music by those composers, but not all of it, and I'm confident a skilled imitator could fool me.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThat's a different problem. Fooling an amateur isn't so hard - as this thread shows. Fooling a musicologist is much harder. David Cope thinks he's done it already. I'm not entirely convinced, but the output of EMI does a reasonable impersonation of pastiche, which is about as good as it gets for now.