3 ms·
I say you're wrong - and I'm saying that as someone who has worked on both. Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven are so complex there are no living human composers who
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
I say you're wrong - and I'm saying that as someone who has worked on both.
Bach, Mozart, and Beethoven are so complex there are no living human composers who can produce convincing imitations - never mind machines.
There are a few people who can do clever improvisations in-the-style-of, but that music completely lacks the big structures, broad relationships, and metaphorical depth of the real thing.
In comparison, electronic pop styles are much more formulaic, and the forms and changes are much more predictable.
I think we're less than ten years away from completely generative pop, vocals, sound design, and all. Good computer generated classical music is going to take quite a while longer.
- mrob 11y agoNo human composer will ever produce convincing imitations because the only test that will be accepted as "convincing" is the judgment of an expert. Experts are familiar with the complete works of those famous composers, so they will immediately know the imitation is an imitation. Their knowledge makes them incapable of unbiased judgment. A blind test is impossible. Even tricking the expert into thinking a new genuine work has been discovered won't help, because they will know that is much less likely than an imitation being written. I've listened to a lot of music by those composers, but not all of it, and I'm confident a skilled imitator could fool me.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThat's a different problem. Fooling an amateur isn't so hard - as this thread shows. Fooling a musicologist is much harder. David Cope thinks he's done it already. I'm not entirely convinced, but the output of EMI does a reasonable impersonation of pastiche, which is about as good as it gets for now.
- mehwoot 11y agoI think we're less than ten years away from completely generative pop, vocals, sound design, and all. I highly doubt this, because of the vocals. Generating coherent appealing lyrics and synthesizing voice to sound natural isn't going to happen in 10 years time. Would be really cool if I was wrong, though.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoSee also, Vocaloid. It's not so different to autotuned vocals now. The most recent versions are already significantly better than the original implementation.
- tehchromic 11y agoFair enough! I agree with your statements on the classic composers, however modern composition in it's highest art forms has moved with the rest of art towards abstraction, accident, pure invention, and contemplation of pure noise. You might say the sound of reality is so complex that no living human composer can produce a convincing imitation either! (in the role of devil's advocate at the crossroads) You might also say that all composers are doing clever improvisations in the style of the sound or reality :} I agree that pop is simpler and more formulaic, but I'd argue that the practice can result in complexity that belies it's seeming simplicity. While simple, pop music is volatile, so a popular form one year might look entirely different than a popular form the next. It isn't driven by the same stylistic conformity as music in the classical periods was. Pop music, when it well done, speaks in many layers, across cultural realities. I know that Bach for example, did the same, but I'd also argue, given the fact that composers are speaking on many levels, that many of those cultural realities are lost to the modern listener, some of whom are appreciating classical music in the mode you describe: an art of big structures, broad relationships, and metaphorical depth about ideas and things that they have no cultural basis to understand (and I think this idea goes a way towards explaining the increasing fragmentation and deconstruction of classical order in the high art of modern musical composition). Therefore machinery might have an easier time reproducing classical music than popular music in spite of it's simpler melodic formulas.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoPop has actually ossified over the last ten years or so. Dubstep is more than fifteen years old now, and the Paul Van Dyk album I've just listened to sounds a lot like the last Paul Van Dyk album a few years ago. Then you get this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=34&v=WySgNm8qH-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=34&v=WySgNm8qH-I and this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FY8SwIvxj8o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FY8SwIvxj8o and the now famous this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I and you start to wonder how much entropy there is to analyse. Modern classical has gone the way of modern art. It's now basically a marketing exercise. The musical experience is secondary. But then I expect creative AIs to be better at marketing too...