29 ms·
So if I were to state "you have no understanding of logic" that would be meaningless? I would argue that the statement does indeed have meaning, because you ha
by shkkmo 11y ago
So if I were to state "you have no understanding of logic" that would be meaningless?
I would argue that the statement does indeed have meaning, because you have some understanding of logic. If the statement had no meaning it would be impossible to disprove.
It is quite possible to create a meaningful definition that has no referent: "My first born child" is a statement that can have at most 1 referent but can also have 0 referents.
Just the fact that it is possible that a definition has 0 referents does not make that definition "a contradiction" or "meaningless".