4 ms·
What a bullshit title. Was the ban really based on the "muslimness" of his name?
by tedunangst 11y ago
What a bullshit title. Was the ban really based on the "muslimness" of his name?
- CamperBob2 11y agoYes, it's a bullshit/flamebait title. This would be an excellent opportunity for an admin to step in and edit the title. Those who are modding you down have no clue how the various government lists work, and what the penalties are for exporting anything to someone on them. Yes, as with most US export law, these lists are arbitrary, feckless, and generally stupid, and yes, they contain a lot of very common names. But the "Muslim"-ness of the name has absolutely nothing to do with anything. (Exactly what is a "Muslim" name, anyway? Am I a Christian because my name is John?)
- mike_hearn 11y agoSDN list is not an export control list, despite that it's maintained by OFAC. Americans are not allowed to trade with people on the SDN even if they live in America and are American citizens: http://ccrjustice.org/home/what-we-do/our-cases/salah-v-us-department-treasury http://ccrjustice.org/home/what-we-do/our-cases/salah-v-us-d... His statement is not wrong. He is caught up in this net because the US Government is waging various kinds of economic warfare against Muslim countries, and one of their tools is literally just a list of names. If USG didn't hate Iran or view the Middle East as a strategic interest, there would not be so many Muslim names on the list and this probably wouldn't have happened to him.
- StavrosK 11y ago"User on list blocked by downloading Sophos AV for Mac"
- qmalxp 11y agoSounds like it was based on the "terrorist"-ness of his name, i.e. whether the name is on a watchlist, which (rightfully or wrongfully, in the West) correlates with "Muslimness".
- davidgerard 11y agoAs the article points out, "Hasan Ali" is a stupendously common Muslim name. Imagine blocking anyone called "John Williams" and then claiming you were blocking terrorists, not just people with English-sounding names. It turns out that in practice (and law), companies are held responsible for grossly discriminatory effects of their actions, without a detailed process of examining motivations at the time.
- wmt 11y agoTerrorists really should start using aliases like "John Williams", "George Bush", "Donald Trump" etc. to circumvent these name lists, as they already managed to max out the patdown ineffectiveness with the shoe bomber and the underwear bomber.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThey could use the name "Ted Kennedy." That'd show 'em. Oops, no, our wonderful, benevolent, and omniscient government is one step ahead of the curve as usual. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17073-2004Aug19.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17073-2004Aug...
- tedunangst 11y agoImagine blocking anybody named "academy of natural sciences" and then claiming you were blocking terrorists, not just organizations devoted to science.
- peeters 11y agoThat's not up to Sophos to know though. Companies are required to comply with the regulations, at the penalty of incredibly stiff penalties. And the cost of paying manual attention to every match would be debilitating. It is much more advantageous for them to automate it and be safe rather than sorry. Their policy of asking for more information on an initial positive match is reasonable. If you want to blame anyone, blame the U.S. agencies who implemented these restrictions. Sophos is just obeying the law.