5 ms·
Maybe I'm too cynical, but my first thought when reading this was, let's see how highly paid professionals react when technology is coming for their jobs. But
by mistermann 11y ago
Maybe I'm too cynical, but my first thought when reading this was, let's see how highly paid professionals react when technology is coming for their jobs.
But of course, a few phone calls, the passing of some additional legislation if needed, and they will be completely protected from any financial ramifications. At least the world will still be a better place if this technology actually works.
- hiou 11y agoIt's much more profitable to replace high wage labor than low skill labor so it makes sense that this segment of the workforce would be replaced sooner than later. I never considered the angle of the additional political power this group has which may end up stalling that process. Excellent point.
- mistermann 11y agoMaybe not a great example: dentistry. While it is surely not "simple", I don't think it is nearly as complex as something like medicine, and it is fundamentally important basic need in everyone's life. But is also extremely expensive, and is often not covered by universal health even in countries where medicine is. So, from time to time you'll hear, typically in ethnic communities in western countries, of non-certified people practicing dentistry off the books. I have no way of knowing what skill level they tend to operate at, but I'd be surprised if it wasn't somewhat equivalent to where mainstream dentistry was at say 20 years ago - so certainly not the best, but far better than nothing. But when it leaks out this is happening, they are shut down immediately. As a comparison, auto mechanics is also quite complicated, but if you literally can't afford to have it dealer serviced, at least you have less-better but affordable alternatives. Not so with dentistry, because they have a powerful industry lobby that sees that any competition is formally illegal, and any freelancers have the full force of the law brought down to stop their practice. The argument for this I imagine would be "public safety", yet auto mechanics also has a public safety aspect, a much larger one I would argue, yet I can buy tools and work on my own car in my garage without breaking any laws. And so it will go as technology progresses, industries and professions with government connections will often be untouchable. The older I get, the more I see a similar pattern recurring everywhere (but in different forms), such as the "Why is rent so high and pay so low" article on the front page of HN today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10024681 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10024681
- zafka 11y agoVery good comparison!! I just pulled my gf's attention away from her ipad to read this to her. My only fear is that rather than loosen up the practice of dentistry, the government will begin tighter licensing on hand tool usage.
- aianus 11y agoProfessional organizations, especially in medicine and law, are a disgusting selfish cabal enriching themselves at the expense of the sick and poor who are then priced out of their services. Fortunately these lobbies are only national. You can always go to Vietnam / India / Whatever and get your non-emergency medical and dental care done there. I got my wisdom teeth out for $30 in Saigon; the only difference (besides $300 in price) was the tools were a little older and I was in an open-floor cubicle instead of a closed office.
- outside1234 11y agowe see this all the time in our industry. CI/CD has replaced a lot of the functions of "Release Engineering", but not all of them, and these folks have moved up the the value chain to solve other issues.
- jws 11y agoThat may not work out. If radiologists block its use, then the next logical customer is malpractice lawyers. Use it to sift potential clients for ones where early indications were missed. After a few of these suits succeed then the hospital industry will have to institute automated analysis as a defensive measure.
- astazangasta 11y agoMy brother is a lawyer, working in some large corporate contracts mill. Their division just got sold to a huge conglomerate and the labor outsourced overseas. This is happening and it is nothing to cheer. The squeeze will slowly move up the food chain until only the billionaires remain.
- mistermann 11y agoNo, it certainly isn't something to cheer, sorry if it sounded that way. I just have this general sense that the huge gap in public opinion on outsourcing & similar matters is almost completely aligned with each individuals income or place on the financial hierarchy - while the lower and middle class are raising an alarm, the well compensated professionals generally have a "tsk tsk, should have got a real education" attitude, or at the very least "there has always been new jobs created, and there will this time as well". I'm fortunate enough (so far) to still have one of those high paying jobs, but I worry a lot about not just myself but for society in general. To me a very likely natural progression is that as the power of technology increases, it will be the well connected monied class who either harness it to make themselves even more wealthy, or at the very least use the courts to protect themselves from harm. So in that sense, while it is unfortunate to read about your brother, at the same time it is encouraging in a strange way that the one profession that you'd think would use the legal system is also being hurt by technology and outsourcing. But it is also discouraging in that it shows once again that those in power (and already have more money than they know how to spend) are willing to even throw "their own" over the side of the ship in the pursuit of even more money to add to their pile. The world is becoming increasingly bizarre every day from a financial perspective. Yesterday I was reading a community bulletin board and see a handwritten "for sale" ad for some household items (plates, scarves, various knick knacks) for like $2 to $10 per item - the whole lot might be $50. That'll buy you like two days of survival, then what? Of course it's good to recycle, and I'm not saying the seller needs this money, but when you can probably go to the dollar store and buy all of those items brand new for the same or lower price, it's kinda like what's the point. Last night I figured I'll sell my old cell phone that I paid $700 for a few years back, spent over an hour wiping it, etc and then check craigslist for going rates, I'll be lucky if I can get $75 for it. All these things kind of invoke a feeling of cognitive dissonance in me, know what I mean? To me the world just seems in many ways to be in almost a logically impossible state of equilibrium at the moment. From everyone freaking out about "peak oil" 5 years ago, suddenly we have massive oversupply of oil and commodities, and it seems plausible that it may remain that way for a very long time, if not indefinitely - which again, could be good or bad depending on your lot in life. How does it all end?
- naveen99 11y agoRadiologist here. Not too worried about watson reading cat scans anytime soon. image segmentation is not a solved problem. Deep belief networks have been doing image classification, not segmentation. I welcome more competition in the radiology Pacs business though; which I think is all this is.
- jpambrun 11y agoPh.D student in medical imaging here.. It is not a question of if but when. I'm sure factory workers thought they would never be replaced by robots.
- orting 11y ago> It is not a question of if but when You can say that about almost anything, and the world is still full of factory workers. As a PhD student in medical imaging, you must also know that getting fully automating segmentation methods to work to the standard required in the clinic is really hard. And once you solve it for one clinic you will likely not be able to transfer the trained model to another clinic, because scan parameters, patients and workflow are different. But when we solve the segmentation task, I think most radiologist will clap their hands and move on.
- lucidrains 11y agoI follow the progress in deep learning too, Radiologists have been close to out of a job since the 80's, but this time may be different. Deep conv nets have basically allowed computers to surpass us in identifying visual patterns. The bottleneck is just the training data.
- easyfrag 11y agoAre there applications of this technology in other areas of radiology as an automated second opinion? Would the culture of Radiology welcome such checks or would it be seen as a threat?
- naveen99 11y ago