30 ms·
Article: "Medical care can be credited with 5 to 5.5 years of the increase in life expectancy since 1900" You: "[The article] starts with the number 5.25 years
by jessriedel 11y ago
Article: "Medical care can be credited with 5 to 5.5 years of the increase in life expectancy since 1900"
You: "[The article] starts with the number 5.25 years...and then calculates "year of life the doctor saved" based on that. That's wrong....The counterexample: the kid breaks the leg....There are immense number of equivalent examples and all are ignored in the article.
Are you claiming that the article only accounts for deaths averted and fails to account for improved health and well being? Because the article addresses disability-adjusted life years literally 2 sentences later.
> Medicine also improves wellbeing: the average person has five more years free of disability.
(Incidentally, deaths averted are comparable in total value to injuries averted, so the article would still fulfill it's claim of getting an order-of-magnitude estimate even if it had ignored the later.)
I would focus less on ad hominems about the author's youth.
- acqq 11y ago> Because the article addresses disability-adjusted life years literally 2 sentences later. Yes, and I claim the article still misses the point. The doctor helping the patient really "saves" the patient life and the life of people in his family every time he/she helps. That's not measurable with QALYs the way it's done in the article, and to understand that, one has to live through the critical periods in his own life or the life of those closest to him, therefore the reference to the view by somebody young. Disclaimer: I've had exactly the same tunnel vision as I was younger, and I'm male, so I write based on my own experience. The averages he calculates are for "what contributes the doctor on average." And the averages are even true: there are enough of doctors that work more for their own benefit that for the benefit of fellow humans. The best example is the UK doctor that started the anti-vaccine craze. He had a lot of impact, and even if he was eventually expelled for having interest in spreading the craze, a lot of people still follow what he started. But if somebody really wants to make a huge positive difference by being a doctor, he really can. Who says that he must work at the hospital in Oxford? How about spending only a few months in some mission in Africa? http://www.msf.org/about-msf http://www.msf.org/about-msf Also, what number of QALYs can be calculated for an average worker of other professions, including those recommended by the 80000 hours site?
- jessriedel 11y agoAll your points are low quality.
- acqq 11y agoInstead of all, please concentrate on only two: - What number of QALYs can be calculated for an average worker of other professions, especially those recommended by the 80000 hours site (e.g. QALYs saved by an average "Think tank researcher")? - Is it even possible to calculate average QALYs in a way to really compare anything meaningful, across the different occupations? If not, why are they here calculated for "average" doctors?
- jessriedel 11y ago> What number of QALYs can be calculated for an average worker of other professions, especially those recommended by the 80000 hours site (e.g. QALYs saved by an average "Think tank researcher")? When you say "average", do you mean a marginal worker of average quality, or the literally the total impact of the profession divided over its total practitioners? The definition really isn't relevant for s careers because we expect diminishing returns, and individuals can only act on the margins. (On the other hand, the government might be interested in it if they had the ability to expand the size of the entire industry.) I don't know what the estimates are, but I would wager heavily that there are identifiable think-tank research positions with much higher leverage, even on the margins, than the highest-impact medical professions. It's just a matter of multipliers: think tanks influenc large amounts of money while doctors generally can't help beyond their own patients. > - Is it even possible to calculate average QALYs in a way to really compare anything meaningful, across the different occupations? If not, why are they here calculated for doctors? Yes, I think an estimate is possible, although there may be large uncertainties. 80k Hours has previously estimated the value (and chance) of things like becoming a member of parliament, or working in finance and donating most of one's salary to health charities in the developing world. Even when these are off by an order of magnitude, they often are sufficiently informative to usefully change people's plans. 80k Hours claims that over 180 people have made serious career changes that those people explicitly attribute to the organization's research.