4 ms·
>AWS billing alerts I don't want alerts, I want a fixed amount limit. If watching this sht was my day job then sure I'd be OK with billing alerts. I'm busy fig
by Havoc 11y ago
>AWS billing alerts
I don't want alerts, I want a fixed amount limit. If watching this sht was my day job then sure I'd be OK with billing alerts. I'm busy fighting other fires in my day job though & often won't see mails for days. By that time Amazon might have bankrupted me.
Amazon has some decent engineers & this is not technically difficult. Its very obviously a concious decision to not provide this very useful feature as any kind of capping feature will negatively impact revenue...but its also literally the only reason why I don't have a paid AWS account for personal use.
- sokoloff 11y agoBilling alerts go to SNS, which can deliver to email, SQS, or Lambda. You can actually automate the response if you want; it doesn't have to be email-read-by-human.
- eropple 11y agoYou're in AWS. Why do you think alerts mean you need to be watching for them? Alerts come from CloudWatch, to SNS, and from that can go wherever you want them to. So do that, with the tools they've already given you. And this lets you kill only what you want to kill--I mean, do you want them to dump all your S3 buckets? Or just, say, down all your EC2 nodes? It's not about capping features being negative for revenue, it's that the customers who want it don't matter; if it's not something a company dropping $20K/month is going to use, I doubt it's really worth the time of day. You are a Linode or DigitalOcean customer, and that's not a bad thing, but I think that AWS is not the right place for you and I think that they know that.
- Havoc 11y ago>from that can go wherever you want them to You miss my point - its not a technical problem. As I said this isn't my day job. Sure a hacker/sysadmin/whatever could re-route the AWS warning to whatever system. For me this would be a hobby/toy though and I can't have a toy that exposes me to a potential multi-thousand bill out of the blue. Thats not a hobby - thats a gamble. As I said in my initial post - its like leveraged derivatives. If I were a day trader living that reality then that kind of uncertain would be acceptable. I'm not a day trader though so I don't want that kind of blank cheque responsibility on something I'm not actively watching.
- eropple 11y agoComplaining that they don't cater to people who don't make them even couch-cushions money and won't use the tools they have to do exactly what they want is really silly. Not all services are intended for all types of customer. Right now in their business lifecycle, you're the kind of customer AWS should fire.
- Havoc 11y ago>won't use the tools they have to do exactly what they want What I want is to reduce my legal liability from unlimited to something less than unlimited. Show me how to do that and I'll concede that you're right & I'm wrong.
- wpietri 11y agoI believe his point is that you aren't their target customer. It's like walking into a freight distribution center and asking to buy $0.50 worth of chewing gum. Sure, somebody might accommodate you, but complaining about them not doing so doesn't make a lot of sense. In Amazon's shoes I'm not sure I'd offer a feature like that at all, because someone might set that to be "smart", forget about it as the business grows, and then have a bunch of servers terminated and/or data destroyed right during an excitingly busy period. It would be an extraordinarily bad customer experience. It could be much better for them to do as now and then occasionally credit people who accidentally go over.
- Havoc 11y ago>I believe his point is that you aren't their target customer. I hear you & understand your argument. They are offering AWS free tier to me for zero USD though, so I don't think my offer of a paid account capped to 200 USD is unreasonable. It is telling though that they won't give free AWS accounts without CC details... I'm not trying to screw amazon here...I just want a little bit of VM time that I can use to toy around with from a reputable source without signing over the rights to my first-born. Maybe I expect to much...dunno.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThey don't really care about small customers. However, they do care about the big customers that started as small customers, and about the engineers who use AWS for their hobby and choose it for their big company just because that's what they're familiar with. It's why they have a free tier.
- benchess 11y agoSo when you hit the limit you want AWS to stop your spending... how? You're spending $/hr on compute, so terminate your instances. Plus your EBS volumes, so delete your drives. Plus... S3? So delete all your data?
- dogecoinbase 11y agoFor development/personal stuff, yes, that is exactly what I want. I want to be able to put a hard cap on my downside. Maybe they can make it a separate account type, maybe the cap can be distinguished by resource type, but for mucking around/side projects/etc it's unsettling to use a resource whose cost is potentially arbitrarily high if something goes wrong.
- Havoc 11y ago>So when you hit the limit you want AWS to stop your spending... how? How? Very abruptly. I can stop the actual spend my side (credit card side) but I need Amazon to implement a legal mechanism that stops me from being legally liable for a (potentially) unlimited amount. Without that its too risky as a personal project...I'll rather do something safer like BASE jumping. >You're spending $/hr on compute, so terminate your instances. If everything goes to plan. hn is full of horror stories about people waking up to bills of people hacking their AWS & mining bitcoins. This would be a toy/hobby/project for me though & I'm painfully aware of my ignorance in this regard. Chances are I will screw up & have a bitcoin mining hacker on my account...hence me needing a hard cap.
- lfowles 11y agoYep, doing budgeting at the end of the month and I found a $20 Amazon charge. Turns out it was from a little bit of data I left on their DB service (which took _a lot_ of clicking to find the one I was actually using) after my free year had expired. Certainly not thousands of dollars, but for just experimenting with the system months ago, it was a rude wakeup call. Ideally I would have been able to say "Never spend more than $0.00, kill any services you have to, I'm _only_ using this for evaluation."
- nadams 11y ago> I don't want alerts, I want a fixed amount limit. I don't think you want AWS - I think you just want a VPS or a dedicated server. AWS is for people who are going to need to scale at large - and you pay a premium for that. I've priced it out - as an individual you get more value from a VPS provider such as DigitalOcean than you do from AWS.
- Havoc 11y ago>I don't think you want AWS - I think you just want a VPS or a dedicated server. Fair point - and perhaps the core of the issue. Since the start of this discussion a friendly hn soul has pointed out that Azure does actually allow hard-capping expenses though - a definite win for MS in my eyes.
- ZainRiz 11y agoFYI, Azure already has monthly spending limits built in and suspends your account once you hit the cap. When you go over your limit your compute services are all turned off and your data is rendered inaccessible until your account is resumed (which happens at the end of the month or when you raise your spending limit). (Full Disclosure: I work for the Azure Web Apps team)
- Havoc 11y ago>FYI, Azure already has monthly spending limits built in and suspends your account once you hit the cap. Perfect. Also seems to support python which suits me. Many thanks friend.