3 ms·
//Somewhat off topic Using any kind of AWS account (in a personal capacity) is a serious risk in my eyes. Its much like I'm happy to take the risk of buying s
by Havoc 11y ago
//Somewhat off topic
Using any kind of AWS account (in a personal capacity) is a serious risk in my eyes.
Its much like I'm happy to take the risk of buying shares, but don't like leveraged derivatives.
I don't want to deal with something that is not my area of expertise and has very real potential to blow up in my face.
I wish Amazon allowed me to cap spending to say 200USD...that I can plan for much easier than X thousands.
- tokenizerrr 11y agoAgreed. Wish I could limit cap the monthly amount spent.
- Havoc 11y agoYup - frankly I'm very wary of anything that is an uncertain amount. Did the same with my cellphone contracts - take expected spend, triple it and make that the limit. Put a number on it (even triple) and I can deal with it...just not liable for "unknown".
- eropple 11y agoIf you look around (or spend a few minutes writing one), you can use a scram switch that goes off of AWS billing alerts.
- CJefferson 11y agoWhat if I'm asleep? Or it fails? Seems so much easier, and safer, for Amazon to just have a hard "don't charge more than this". Increasingly, I wish this could be fixed at the banking end -- I'd like to be able to get my bank to enforce that I won't give more than £X to some company (obviously the company should be able to find this fact out, and not give me products worth more than £X).
- toomuchtodo 11y agoUse prepaid cards you load with a fixed sum.
- CJefferson 11y agoI imagine Amazon would still come after you in court for the rest of the money?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoDo you authorize Amazon to charge an unlimited amount? You do not.
- Havoc 11y ago>Do you authorize Amazon to charge an unlimited amount? You do not. You do. That exactly is the problem & why I started this off-topic angle thread bitching about the lack of limits. You can limit the actual charge on the credit card, but I see nothing capping the legal liability. i.e. They could in theory reposes your home because of an unpaid AWS account. In theory - I'd love to have someone prove me I'm wrong in this thinking. Until someone does though...this seems way too risky for a hobby/toy.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> They could in theory reposes your home because of an unpaid AWS account. Technically, no. I doubt Amazon would risk the publicity and attempt to garnish your wages or pursue your assets; you could, of course, declare bankruptcy to protect your home from their judgement if they went so far as to obtain one.
- Havoc 11y ago>Technically, no. I doubt Amazon would risk the publicity No? There is a big difference between "Technically no" and "uh they probably won't" - especially when it comes to legal matters. Remember the home repossession was an example - I don't even fall under US law. The house thing was code for "legally the can wipe you off the map".
- eropple 11y agoWhy would it matter if you're asleep? It's the cloud, if you're not automating things you're doin' it wrong. I wouldn't do that, but you've already put costs ahead of uptime, so burning it down should be fine, yeah? Amazon's market is largely not people who are worried about those kinds of overages, and I can't really blame them for not worrying about these kinds of edge cases.
- Havoc 11y ago>AWS billing alerts I don't want alerts, I want a fixed amount limit. If watching this sht was my day job then sure I'd be OK with billing alerts. I'm busy fighting other fires in my day job though & often won't see mails for days. By that time Amazon might have bankrupted me. Amazon has some decent engineers & this is not technically difficult. Its very obviously a concious decision to not provide this very useful feature as any kind of capping feature will negatively impact revenue...but its also literally the only reason why I don't have a paid AWS account for personal use.
- sokoloff 11y agoBilling alerts go to SNS, which can deliver to email, SQS, or Lambda. You can actually automate the response if you want; it doesn't have to be email-read-by-human.
- eropple 11y agoYou're in AWS. Why do you think alerts mean you need to be watching for them? Alerts come from CloudWatch, to SNS, and from that can go wherever you want them to. So do that, with the tools they've already given you. And this lets you kill only what you want to kill--I mean, do you want them to dump all your S3 buckets? Or just, say, down all your EC2 nodes? It's not about capping features being negative for revenue, it's that the customers who want it don't matter; if it's not something a company dropping $20K/month is going to use, I doubt it's really worth the time of day. You are a Linode or DigitalOcean customer, and that's not a bad thing, but I think that AWS is not the right place for you and I think that they know that.
- Havoc 11y ago>from that can go wherever you want them to You miss my point - its not a technical problem. As I said this isn't my day job. Sure a hacker/sysadmin/whatever could re-route the AWS warning to whatever system. For me this would be a hobby/toy though and I can't have a toy that exposes me to a potential multi-thousand bill out of the blue. Thats not a hobby - thats a gamble. As I said in my initial post - its like leveraged derivatives. If I were a day trader living that reality then that kind of uncertain would be acceptable. I'm not a day trader though so I don't want that kind of blank cheque responsibility on something I'm not actively watching.
- impostervt 11y agoI actually had a billing alert set, and I did get an alert, but it looked like this: "You are receiving this email because your estimated charges are greater than the limit you set for the alarm "awsbilling-AWS-Service-Charges-total" in AWS Account XXXXXXXX. The alarm limit you set was $ 10.00 USD. Your total estimated charges accrued for this billing period are currently $ 1050.95 USD as of Saturday 18 July, 2015 17:34:36 UTC." So, it came a bit too late to take action.
- declan 11y ago>I wish Amazon allowed me to cap spending to say 200USD... Agreed. We use Google App Engine for our recommendation engine (https://recent.io/ https://recent.io/) and daily budgets are a core feature -- just tap on the "Application settings" tab. We use AWS for some additional components of our service that aren't part of the core recommendation engine, and I've been surprised by the lack of a maximum-dollars-per-day setting. Or if there is one, I'm not aware of it.
- paulsimps 11y agoDo you know if the daily budget works for App Engine Managed VMs as well? I want to use them for a personal project, but was unsure if the daily budget would stop overcharging since they are using Compute Engine underneath.
- manigandham 11y agoI think people are forgetting how hard this can be... an EC2 server is easy enough to turn off but AWS has dozens of services charged at very fine-grained levels. How exactly are they supposed to stop spend? The only way would be to completely reset the entire account, otherwise you'd still be accruing charges just for data at rest or incoming requests or anything else passive. A complete account reset doesn't seem like a feature that's very useful or something they'd want to implement because it would likely cause more trouble then help fix.