2 ms·
Why is it a bad thing for Kim Dotcom to make money by using copyrighted works without the permission of the copyright holders, but a good thing for Microsoft to
by mikeash 11y ago
Why is it a bad thing for Kim Dotcom to make money by using copyrighted works without the permission of the copyright holders, but a good thing for Microsoft to do it?
Edit: my works are protected by copyright just as much as anything Megaupload hosted. You appear to believe that the license on them is not legally binding. In which case, fair enough, but then standard copyright applies, which doesn't give anyone permission to redistribute them. As for malice, you repeatedly said you wanted to see Microsoft violate these licenses intentionally in order to invalidate them, so you seem to think it would be a good thing even if it's not what they actually did in this case.
Edit edit: you're right, if I release X and the license for X is invalid, then I have released X with no terms of use. With no terms of use, then the standard copyright protections written into the laws of the relevant jurisdictions apply without modification. In the case of US copyright law (which applies to both me and Microsoft) that says they can't redistribute my stuff without my permission. "No terms of use" does not equate to "therefore you can do anything you want."
Edit the third: what do you mean, "default back to you"? If you're right and the license holds no weight, then I never gave up those rights in the first place.
Edit the last: so your theory is that the part of my license which says "you can redistribute this" is legally valid, but the part which says "under the following conditions" is not? That's certainly an interesting legal theory. I am not convinced, to put it mildly.
OK, one more: how should those conditions be written in order to be valid?
- geofft 11y agoYeah, I am pretty curious about this theory of law where a judge can rule that a right ceases to exist. That's not what I understand a "right" to be. Anyway, mikeash, you're spending way too much time caring. There's certainly good work to be done in making copyright law clear to hackers, but it won't help people who don't understand basic principles of law. Your time is better spent on more fruitful things. :)