4 ms·
An (especially unhinged) HNer. We really added a lot of value to that github discussion over there. :( https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=MTWomg https://n
by justin66 11y ago
An (especially unhinged) HNer. We really added a lot of value to that github discussion over there. :(
https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=MTWomg https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=MTWomg
- mikeash 11y agoThe irony of the comment calling Kim Dotcom a "piece of shit" is just astounding in context. I was afraid my post might generate some crap in the comments over there, but I hope it's a net gain overall!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justin66 11y ago> I was afraid my post might generate some crap in the comments over there, but I hope it's a net gain overall! The "I can assure you that I do not read HN and am far more intelligent than you" comment from MTWomg was amusing but overall I'm afraid that one guy is capable of doing more damage to an unmoderated conversation than the rest of us are capable of mitigating. (how would we actually do that?)
- geofft 11y agoIt isn't really unmoderated, since the repository owner can delete comments. I'm pretty disappointed that they did not do so. However, last I heard, the only way to ban a user from a GitHub organization's issue tracker (as opposed to an individual's) is to contact support.
- justin66 11y agoIf I were that guy I'd be more focused on working the problem. Although public perception is half of that, so yeah, that is a decent point.
- MTWomg 11y agoAgain with this nonsense. Damage is not the same thing as 'thing I disagree with'. Try again.
- jsmthrowaway 11y ago> I was afraid my post might generate some crap in the comments over there, but I hope it's a net gain overall! With respect, it genuinely isn't. Nothing changed from you submitting this thread, because the resolutions were already in flight by the time this hit the front page.
- MTWomg 11y agoKim Dotcom knowingly ran a criminal origination with the intent and purpose of turning piracy into a money maker for him/the company. The US indictment lays this out very clearly, with proof. EDIT: RE "Why is it a bad thing for Kim Dotcom to make money by using copyrighted works without the permission of the copyright holders, but a good thing for Microsoft to do it?" Well, for one thing, the works that Kim was making money off of have valid legal protection - proven, codified into law. The real reason is malice - MS inadvertently failed to include the licenses. Kim structured Megaupload so as to reward the users who uploaded pirated content in great scale. Employees were aware of this usage of Megaupload - that it was effectively the only use of Megaupload, that the site was funded by the money piracy generated, etc etc etc. Instead of stopping this criminal act, employees emailed links to pirated content hosted on Megaupload to one another. Does any of this sound like what, say, Dropbox would do? RE RE: No, your works do not have the same protection that the works of the massive companies that Megaupload victimized have. Depending upon your license, your works may have no protection at all. Copyright does not protect you - if you release X and the license for X is invalid in whole, you have released X with no terms of use. The Follow? That's a gross simplification, but it will suffice. I wanted to see Microsoft deliberately violate GPL, but that does not show malice; I want X, but they did not do X. RE RE RE: Not quite right. Rights do not automatically default back to you in an instance of your license being restrictive in an illegal matter. A Judge makes that call, and the call very well may be to allow the existing userbase rights to the work in question. The 'default' does not necessarily apply in instances of abuse. RE RE RE RE: You established an install base through an unlawful license. The users do not automatically lose rights to given to them under that unlawful license. There is a human involved here. The human is unlikely to punish your users to resolve your wrongdoing. See, the license in question gives users X set of rights and one restriction: 'include my name in derivative works' Your license is illegal in whole, but your intent was to assign this set of permissions/restrictions. The license in question could be written so as to comply with the law, but as it stands it does not appear to do so. The exact same 'credit me' thing is possible to do legally. As such, I don't see a human striking the license down without further action resembling a requirement for the software to be relicensed, with users able to acquire this new license if they so choose. In the real world, the one creator does not matter any where near as much as the army of users. Decisions are made to protect the users interests. RE RE RE RE RE: "Edit the last: so your theory is that the part of my license which says "you can redistribute this" is legally valid, but the part which says "under the following conditions" is not? That's certainly an interesting legal theory. I am not convinced, to put it mildly." Both parts could be valid, but in the form they are written are not. As it stands, neither part is valid. A human being (judge) would/should look at the license, see the intent of the creator and resolve the issue. RE RE RE RE RE RE: I am not prepared to tackle that massive task.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoAs I said in-thread, I've now promoted my back burner idea to allow repository owners to automatically lock GitHub threads when they appear here. There are a couple missing pieces from GitHub's end, namely API support and the ability to lock "other" threads like commits, so I suspect the functionality will become deleting non-owner/non-collaborator comments after a thread appears here. There are GitHub accounts like MTWomg whose sole purpose is trolling when a thread appears here, and it's becoming simply irresponsible to divert this community's conversation to another community. I have contacted GitHub for clarity on these points, since as it stands, it seems like locking was a kneejerk "put out a fire" mechanism that is really unsupported and betrays GitHub not caring about abuse on their platform. They join Twitter in that regard. HN destroys threads more than Reddit, in my experience, but both are worth hitting.
- MTWomg 11y agoAh! There you are. As I said on Github, I do not regularly read HN and was not made aware of the issue through HN. You have no way of knowing when and how I was made aware of the Github issue. Do not pretend, you look silly when you do. I was not even aware that this 'thing' was on HN until you mentioned it. A position you disagree with is not abuse. I am not targeting a specific person and forcing them to read my posting, I am responding to an issue with a valid perspective. This is far removed from the kind of awful harassment that happens on Twitter all day, every day.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoFollowing me from platform to platform is not going to get me to engage you. Remain irrelevant, please.
- MTWomg 11y agoI propose that you learned of the Github Issue when s5msft flapped their wings and flew to your home, landed on your shoulder and telepathically communicated the issue to you. You get it yet?