5 ms·
I like the dude who thinks that the GPL hasn't been proven valid in a US court and that migueldeicaza has trouble getting a job in the industry.
by geofft 11y ago
I like the dude who thinks that the GPL hasn't been proven valid in a US court and that migueldeicaza has trouble getting a job in the industry.
- cannam 11y agoit's quite irrelevant, but I was about to post the same -- the idea of Miguel "becoming unemployable" as a result of this is just delightful.
- geofft 11y agoYeah. Ironically, what would actually make me hesitate to hire someone is seeing them post on a public issue tracker that they believe the GPL is unenforceable and that blatantly violating it is a good idea. Leaving aside their critical thinking abilities, soft skills, etc. it's a serious risk of legal liability to have such a person write code for my company.
- mikeash 11y agoIndeed. They seem eager for Microsoft to intentionally violate the GPL in order to create a court case which they believe would result in invalidating the GPL. Who's to say they wouldn't see an opportunity for causing this to happen by incorporating GPL into whatever project they're working on at their job?
- CHY872 11y agoI hope that some day I may join him too at 'Unemployable Island'
- cannam 11y agoyou wish! they don't hire just anyone, at 'Unemployable Island'
- MTWomg 11y agoThe idea of Miguel getting a job outside of the open sores bubble is also delightful. Maybe mopping floors?
- justin66 11y agoAn (especially unhinged) HNer. We really added a lot of value to that github discussion over there. :( https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=MTWomg https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=MTWomg
- mikeash 11y agoThe irony of the comment calling Kim Dotcom a "piece of shit" is just astounding in context. I was afraid my post might generate some crap in the comments over there, but I hope it's a net gain overall!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- justin66 11y ago> I was afraid my post might generate some crap in the comments over there, but I hope it's a net gain overall! The "I can assure you that I do not read HN and am far more intelligent than you" comment from MTWomg was amusing but overall I'm afraid that one guy is capable of doing more damage to an unmoderated conversation than the rest of us are capable of mitigating. (how would we actually do that?)
- geofft 11y agoIt isn't really unmoderated, since the repository owner can delete comments. I'm pretty disappointed that they did not do so. However, last I heard, the only way to ban a user from a GitHub organization's issue tracker (as opposed to an individual's) is to contact support.
- justin66 11y agoIf I were that guy I'd be more focused on working the problem. Although public perception is half of that, so yeah, that is a decent point.
- MTWomg 11y ago
- danbruc 11y agoBut he is also partly correct, the way some of the comments are phrased is pretty childish, rude or whatever you want to call it.
- cortesoft 11y agoThat person has a lot of very strong opinions about opensource for someone who has never made a single commit to any public repository.