3 ms·
But I thought PC couldn't count a officer's inarticulable hunch towards that "totality of the circumstances". For example, let's say that the dog is not suffic
by SilasX 11y ago
But I thought PC couldn't count a officer's inarticulable hunch towards that "totality of the circumstances".
For example, let's say that the dog is not sufficient probable cause. Consider the cases:
1) drug dog indicates + suspect driving erratically
2) drug dog indicates + "I just have a feeling"
Am I correct that 1) might be PC but 2) could not be, no matter how accurate that officer turns out to be in practice?
(In case 2, the dog's finding more drugs than the base rate would not validate its accuracy, as the results are being pre-filtered to have a very different distribution.)
- rayiner 11y agoIf they're finding drugs at several times the base rate, the officer's suspicions probably aren't an "inarticulate hunch."
- SilasX 11y agoThe term I used was inarticulable, and if you are unable to articulate something (like to a judge), then that makes it inarticulable -- irrespective of how otherwise grounded it was. So rationally, the cop's "spidey sense" is indeed evidence. The question I posed to you (and whoever's reading) was whether it counts as legal evidence. And it's my understanding that, no matter how good your spidey sense is, it does not become PC in a legal sense until it is articulable. As Thomas Moore said in A Man for All Seasons: "The world must construe according to its wits; this court, according to the law."
- CPLX 11y agoThere's no objective way to determine a base rate here. If you argue there is what methodology are you using?