3 ms·
I don't understand how this would work. You can't turn money into bees. You can turn bees into more bees, and money can be used to persuade people to put in mor
by mikeash 11y ago
I don't understand how this would work. You can't turn money into bees. You can turn bees into more bees, and money can be used to persuade people to put in more effort to make this happen, but at some point the bees themselves have to be reproducing.
I thought the whole problem with colony collapse and the honeybee crisis was that bees were declining and nobody knew how to stop it. If you can stop it with money, maybe that's not ideal, but is it a major problem anymore?
- bronson 11y agoYou can't stop it with money, but you can reduce it with more human labor/management. And money buys human labor. And, even though people are figuring out how to deal with the problem, that doesn't mean that the problem is over.
- mikeash 11y agoIf the problem is fewer bees, and money is able to compensate by creating more bees, then there is no problem. If you view the problem as being that bees are being killed by something, then yes, this doesn't solve the problem. But isn't the problem ultimately how many bees you have, not the rate at which they're reproducing and dying? The comment I replied to seems to be implying that the death of the honeybee is still nigh, and that this extra money is just temporarily hiding it. But how could that be?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bronson 11y ago> [if] money is able to compensate by creating more bees, then there is no problem. The problem comes when "creating" more bees becomes too expensive/difficult, and you can no longer afford it. In HN terms: a little cash infusion can make everything look great... until it runs out. Edit: this comment does a much better job of using HN terms: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10024771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10024771
- mikeash 11y agoThat's the trouble, all this startup mumbo jumbo makes no sense to me! Anyway, I think these analogies fail because they keep talking about investors, where you're supposed to be spending money up front for a great return later on. If you're spending more and more money to maintain the same future return then you're in trouble. But things like money spent on bees and honey prices are just straightforward money-for-product transactions.
- 001sky 11y agoThe empirical existence of rising marginal cost (as you point out) is not evidence of non-viability. Every economic 101 good is thought to be produced until its marginal cost is sloping upward. Economically coherent industries will continue to produce widgets. And increasing costs do not simply make an industry incoherent. Both social value ($demand/subsidization) and technology (cost/difficulty) come into play. It seems a bit arbitrary to make adverse assumptions about future ecosystems a bit more evidence.
- bronson 11y agoAbsolutely agreed. And it's a bit arbitrary to make favorable assumptions about future ecosystems (as this article does) without a bit more evidence too. Since the colonies are still collapsing without explanation, a modicum of pessimism might be understandable, even if it isn't completely justifiable.
- tdaltonc 11y agoBy segregating a colony in a clean room with high quality feed and optimal conditions you could quickly bulk and split colonies. That would basically turn money in to bees.
- schiffern 11y ago"Don't worry, the rich will still be able to afford honey made in a clean room! No problems here!!" (you, on the other hand, can have high fructose corn syrup and pesticide and fertilizer-contaminated water)
- icebraining 11y agoThe argument is that either the honey gets more expensive, or all other food does. If you want to refute that as a false choice, you need more than populist rhetoric.
- saalweachter 11y agoIt's not quite money into bees, and it's not quite more human effort. The problem is that building up a new hive is a lot of work for the bees themselves. A new hive needs to collect its own store of honey, raise the new comb to put this new honey in, and raise a lot of new bees to collect the honey, raise the comb, and tend the bee larva. All of this takes a lot of time and energy, and the bees will not be able to collect pollen and nectar as fast while under-beed, so the bees will produce a lot less extra honey for the beekeepers to harvest. From a survival-of-bees perspective, the critical point is the point at which you can no longer split the surviving hives enough times each year to replace the ones lost overwintering; we're still probably a long ways off from that point. From a beekeeping and honey perspective, the problem is that you essentially can't count on hives that are new or were split to generate any extra honey for harvest. This means that you need to increase the total number of hives being kept to harvest the same amount of honey. If you want to be able to harvest honey from 100 hives each year, you may need to keep 400 hives around -- 200 will die in the winter, 100 will be used to generate 200 new hives to replace the ones lost overwintering, and the last 100 you can actually take honey off of, which was your goal all along.