3 ms·
I am not a professional dog trainer, meaning I do not have a CPDT certification nor do people pay me. However, I have extensive experience training dogs at a lo
by mikestew 11y ago
I am not a professional dog trainer, meaning I do not have a CPDT certification nor do people pay me. However, I have extensive experience training dogs at a local dog shelter (minimum two hours/week) in a specific training atmosphere, and I have a fair amount of experience with "nose works" which is somewhat related to "drug sniffing dogs" (nose works is where a drug dog might start, for instance). In other words, if software didn't pay so darned well I could go jump through the hoops and hang out my dog trainer shingle. I also hang out with a lot of trainers who are certified and paid for their work.
With my (albeit weak) credentials out of the way, my quasi-professional opinion is that drug dogs are the polygraph test of the drug war. I've watched bomb and drug dogs at work, and much like a polygraph, I think you can read anything you want into the dog's actions. And unless you're 100% consistent (and even pros aren't), the dog might mis-read the handler. There are retired women who devote way too much time to the "nose works" sport with their dog(s), and in competition even those dogs get it wrong a fair percentage of the time.
For bomb sniffing and sniffing for bodies after a disaster, that's fine. Dog says there's explosives, turns out Fido was wrong, no biggie. A few folks got unnecessarily riled up, but no other harm done. Dog said it found a body, but there's nothing but rubble? Meh, did some digging we didn't have to do, but otherwise little harm done (though we could have been digging for a real person).
Sniffing for drugs? False positives have a greater impact. And just because the dog hit, and there were drugs, doesn't mean the dog was right. Correlation and causation and all that, I suppose. Anyway, I'm explaining this poorly, but I hope the gist gets across.
TLDR: I spend a lot of time around dogs trying to teach them things. They might be more reliable than a polygraph, but I'm not willing to ruin people's day or lives over the word of a dog.