3 ms·
Mathematicians will tell you that the inequality is undefined for x=1.5, and is otherwise satisfied for x>1.0. Yes, the inequality simplifies, but when x=1.5 y
by RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago
Mathematicians will tell you that the inequality is undefined for x=1.5, and is otherwise satisfied for x>1.0.
Yes, the inequality simplifies, but when x=1.5 you are multiplying both sides by 0 which is not a permitted operation.
In this case nothing goes wrong if you blindly simplify and use the simpler inequality. Mathematicians go ballistic when you do that because there are other occasions where similar operations create nonsense. The usual proof that 1=2 is an example.
Trying to show why this sort of thing is wrong is like trying to show that a fallacious proof of a true theorem is wrong. Counter-examples are hard to produce because the theorem is true.
And that's why it's a general rule. If you are dividing by something you have to preclude the possibility that the denominator is 0.